In-depth baby product reviews led by a Pediatrician

Best Nursing Pillow

Credit: Abriah Wofford
By Juliet Spurrier, MD, Wendy Schmitz, and BabyGearLab Review Team
Thursday December 3, 2020
  • Share this article:
Our Editors independently research, test, and rate the best products. We only make money if you purchase a product through our links, and we never accept free products from manufacturers. Learn more
Are you searching for the best nursing pillow? After thorough research and testing, we selected the top 11 nursing pillows of 2020. With over a decade's worth of testing information from more than 20 different pillows, and even more hands-on nursing experience, our baby experts have been around. Finding a nursing pillow that functions well is essential to your breastfeeding success and enjoyment. After reviewing the quality, stability, ease of cleaning, and functionality of each pillow, we provide the information you need to find the best pillow for you and your baby.

1

Best Overall Nursing Pillow


Blessed Nest Organic Nesting


Blessed Nest Organic Nesting
Editors' Choice Award
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

$94.00
at Amazon
See It

Machine-Washable: Cover only | Belt: No
Organic, great quality
Adjustable
Versatile
Expensive
Heavy

We love the Blessed Nest Organic Nesting pillow. This pillow stands out among the competition because it's filling is organic buckwheat hulls instead of foam. What the buckwheat offers is moldability that forms to your body and your growing baby. This superior, somewhat customizable support means no awkward hunching or utilizing additional pillows to get your baby's head at the right height for feeding. We appreciate the versatility of the Blessed Nest because it also makes a great pregnancy support pillow. This pillow with high-quality materials is sure to last. The GOTS certified outer organic cover is easy to remove for washing, and you'll feel good about your baby's sensitive skin resting on the material. It does an adequate job absorbing spit-up before it reaches the inner pillow, and you can toss the pillow body in the dryer to help keep things sanitary and free from dust mites. We appreciate the organic material in this pillow, so your baby isn't inhaling toxic fumes 5-8 hours a day.

One drawback is that the buckwheat makes this pillow heavy. At approximately 5 1/2 lbs, it can feel like a lot when you add the baby's weight on top, especially if you've had a c-section. We recommend using the "football" hold until you heal to help avoid discomfort. This product is also one of the most expensive pillows in this review, but the higher price gives you organic, high-quality materials, so you can justify the cost if your budget allows.

Read Review: Blessed Nest Organic Nesting

2

Best Lumbar Support Pillow


My Brest Friend Deluxe


My Brest Friend Deluxe
Editors' Choice Award
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

$40.42
(16% off)
at Amazon
See It

Machine Washable: Cover only | Belt: Yes
Offers good back support
Pocket
Stays in place
Velcro strap
Foam degrades over time
Difficult to put on

My Brest Friend Deluxe is a unique, wrap-around pillow. The thick band that wraps around your back provides support to help with any nursing strain, and the wrap-around style keeps the pillow in place so your baby can stay latched. Traditional C-shaped pillows tend to shift and need regular adjusting while nursing. Constant adjustment is not the case with the Brest Friend. Once it is secure, you'll have a firm but soft surface for nursing. We also appreciate the pocket feature. It is a convenient place to keep everything from burp cloths to nipple cream or your phone. When purchasing the Deluxe version of the pillow, you will get a soft and snuggly slipcover, perfect for babies with sensitive skin.

While we love many things about this option, the foam's quality is disappointing, and there is no cover beside the slipcover. Some users note that the foam can fall apart when you remove the slipcover for cleaning. Also, the wrap-around style can be a bit of a pain to put on. Connecting the straps around your body can be challenging while holding a baby, and we suspect some moms will stop using the belt over time. The wrap also utilizes Velcro. While you can remove it with the silent release straps (whew!), the Velcro sticking to other materials can be annoying. Overall, we think the pluses outweigh the negatives, making this an option we highly recommend.

Read Review: My Brest Friend Deluxe

3

Best Bang for the Buck Classic


Boppy Bare Naked


Boppy Bare Naked
Best Value Award
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

$29.84
at Amazon
See It

Machine Washable: Yes | Belt: No
Multiple slipcovers available
Great quality
Multiple uses
Doesn't fit all sizes
Flattens out
Shifts

If you have been around nursing mothers in the past 25+ years, you've probably heard of the Boppy. The Boppy is classic, and the Boppy Bare Naked lets you decide which cover you like best (a variety of options sold separately). The most popular are the polyester/cotton blend Boppy Classic Slipcover and the utilitarian water-resistant Boppy Protective Slipcover that reduces the need for washing. Alternatively, the Boppy Luxe provides the pillow with a soft and minky feel with thick piping for extra pampering. The Boppy is super versatile in design. While most parents buy the pillow for breast or bottle-feeding their baby, it has multiple extended uses. Parents have found that the Boppy is a useful tool during tummy time, extra support for sitting up, and a comfy place for playing or resting. The great quality of the pillow allows for years of use.

While the Boppy fits a good range of body types, it is not a one size fits all pillow. Some postpartum women, along with some men, will find it doesn't fit them very well. It can also shift while feeding, especially if your baby is extra squirmy. The pillow can pull away from the stomach, which creates a gap. Finally, while we think the product's quality is high and typically lasts for a long time, the pillow will flatten somewhat with regular use. Overall, this pillow is a classic for a reason; it is comfortable, versatile, and will last for years after your nursing days are over.

Read Review: Boppy Bare Naked

4

Best Pillow for Twins


Twin Z


Twin Z
Top Pick Award
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

$129.99
at Amazon
See It

Machine Washable: Cover only | Belt: Yes
6-in-1
Back support
Comfortable
Very large
Flattens out over time

The Twin Z is the answer for a twin pillow. While it is perfect for breastfeeding, it can also serve other purposes. The pillow's versatile nature allows for bottle feeding, tummy time, pregnancy, support when babies are sitting, and a toddler pillow. It is a comfortable spot to lay babies down at an incline for anything from helping with reflux to looking at books. The pillow is different than other models as it has a centerpiece that folds up to go behind mom's back while feeding, offering some much welcome back support.

The Twin Z is quite large, making it a comfortable spot for twins, but it makes feeding them in a chair somewhat of a chore. You'll likely need to nurse on a couch, bed, or floor to accommodate the pillow's width. The size also impacts the pillow's ability to travel. Also, the interior of the cushion is 100% cotton and will flatten some with use. Overall, the versatility this pillow provides for parents of twins is hard to beat.

Shopping for twins?
An alternative to the Twin Z is the My Brest Friend Twin Plus. Each product has pros and cons, so you'll need to consider which choice best meets your needs.

5

Best for Travel


Luna Lullaby Lil Something


Luna Lullaby Lil Something
Top Pick Award
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

$27.00
List Price
See It

Machine Washable: Cover only | Belt: No
Comfortable
Compact
Great price
Too soft
Can only wash the cover

The Luna Lullaby Lil Something is the perfect nursing pillow for the mom on the go. It is compact but effective, making it an ideal fit for your carry-on bag or the basket of your stroller. This pillow is helpful tummy time support with the soft plush material and curved shape, and we appreciate that it is made in the U.S.A. and contains no flame retardants. All of this, at a great price, makes this pillow one of our top choices.

While we love this product's plush and cozy feel, some users feel the pillow is too soft or too small to offer any real support. This problem can cause your baby to sink in, the parent to hunch over, or allow the pillow to slide away from you. Also, the pillow itself is not machine washable, which seems like an oversight. While you can wash the cover, babies often make messes that penetrate the cover creating an impossible situation.

Heading on travel?
If the Luna isn't your thing, the littlebeam is another excellent travel nursing pillow to consider.

Read Review: Luna Lullaby Lil Something

6

Best for Posture


Ergobaby Natural Curve


Ergobaby Natural Curve
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5


$54.99
at Amazon
See It

Machine Washable: Cover Only | Belt: No
Reduces slouching
Ergonomic
Machine-washable cover
No belt strap
Very firm
Not multi-functional

The Ergobaby Natural Curve is an ergonomically shaped, polyurethane foam nursing pillow. It is firm, free from flame retardants, and has a removable cover that is washing machine-friendly. The pillow's thoughtfully designed shape allows for belly-to-belly breastfeeding and keeps the baby's head above their stomach. The firmness of the material does not lose shape over time. Ergobaby claims that the extra support will help to prevent slouching and back strain while breastfeeding.

This pillow has a much more purpose-specific design and may not be as versatile as others. The qualities that make it an excellent nursing pillow prevent it from being useful in other capacities. For example, it is not soft enough to be a comfortable backrest for mom, and it is a bit too structured to use as a support pillow for baby. There is no belt strap on the Natural Curve, and some moms found that it was difficult to keep the pillow properly positioned without it. However, we found very few flaws with this pillow overall. If you are okay with purchasing a single-function product and would like something to help support good posture, the Ergobaby is a good choice.

Read Review: Ergobaby Natural Curve

7

Double-Sided for Age-optimized Comfort


Boppy Best Latch


Boppy Best Latch
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5


$40.49
(10% off)
at Amazon
See It

Machine Washable: Yes | Belt: Yes
Dual-sided
Buckle feature
Washing machine friendly
Clasp behind back
Pillow eventually sags

The Boppy Best Latch is a dual-sided breastfeeding pillow. It offers a firm side, great for newborns, and a plush side for older babies. The softer side also feels nice on your lap. This Boppy is a thicker pillow and should work well for moms with longer torsos. The pillow offers a buckle that helps keep it from sliding around, so your baby stays nice and close to you. The pillow can be machine washed, which is welcome and rare in this kind of product. While you can't remove the cover for washing, we like knowing that a spit up or diaper leak isn't saturating the pillow's interior.

The buckle on this product could use an upgrade because it isn't the easiest to use. The buckle sits behind your back, which can be uncomfortable to lean on. The pillow can also be prone to sagging after a few months, and you may find yourself wishing for extra support. Overall, we like this pillow, and the dual side feature is hard to beat.

Read Review: Boppy Best Latch

8

Plushness in an Open "L" Design


Luna Lullaby Bosom Baby


Luna Lullaby Bosom Baby
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5


$59.00
List Price
See It

Machine Washable: Cover only | Belt: No
Easy to use
Comfortable/plush
Fits larger body types
Pillow is not machine washable
Large
Expensive

The Luna Lullaby Bosom Baby is a super plush nursing pillow. Moms and babies enjoy how comfortable it is, and the cozy cover comes in multiple patterns and colors. The fabric is fleece-like and ideal for cool weather feedings. The L-shape makes it easy to use and adjust, and the shape fits plus-size moms more easily than pillows like the Boppy Bare Naked.

This pillow can be overwhelming for petite moms and small infants, thanks to its larger size. The material is so soft that it can compress, and the baby can slide into the gap. While the cover is washable, the inner cushion is not. This lack of washability is a bummer because we know that little ones can make big messes. This product is more expensive than much of the competition in this review. So, while there are some things to consider before purchase, many moms love their Bosom Baby.

Read Review: Luna Lullaby Bosom Baby

9

Innovative Adjustable Design


Infantino Elevate


Infantino Elevate
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5


$38.72
(3% off)
at Amazon
See It

Machine Washable: Yes | Belt: No
Multi-level comfort
Can be hands-free
Good quality
Middle section awkward
Scratchy material
Too firm

The Infantino Elevate is an interesting twist on a dilemma facing several nursing moms. Some moms feel that nursing pillows lack the height to get the baby to the breast without slumping and hunching in an uncomfortable position. The "book-like" style of the pad allows you to flip support layers to get the baby's head to the best height for breastfeeding with less strain for mom. This adjustability can create a hands-free device, which is convenient. It also assists babies that need more of an incline because of reflux issues. Also, moms with longer torsos or larger bosoms seemed to have an easier time with this pillow than moms with a more petite build. This pillow is sturdy and durable.

The middle section of this product seems to create a lump that presses into the middle of the baby's back. And the multi-tiered system can prevent getting the baby close enough to the breast. Also, while the quality is durable, it may come at the cost of scratchy material and firm padding. Overall, if you are struggling to find a pillow that is right for your shape and size, the Elevate is a versatile choice worth trying.

10

Great for C-Sections and Away from Home


Lansinoh Nursie


Lansinoh Nursie
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5


$21.99
(12% off)
at Amazon
See It

Machine Washable: Yes | Belt: No
Compact
Good for c-sections
Comfortable
Not good for small infants
Gets hot and sweaty
Wish there were other designs/covers

The Lansinoh Nursie is a good choice for those who want to avoid wrapping a pillow around their waist. The style is different than your typical nursing pillow because you slide it onto your arm to raise your baby to the appropriate height to feed, versus sitting on your lap. This design is nice for moms recovering from a c-section, as it relieves the pressure that a wrap-around pillow can place on the incision site. The pillow is more compact than the traditional counterparts, making it a nice solution for travel or to keep in the car. The soft plush material is super comfortable, and the entire pillow is easy to wash by tossing it into the washing machine.

We feel this option is great for older babies, but tiny infants or first time nursing moms may struggle with nursing one-handed, as it can often take two to get a good latch. Also, the soft, cozy material can get warm and make you sweaty. While we like the gender-neutral design, we wish there were different covers for purchase as the white fabric looks pretty until the first stain. Overall, this pillow can fill a niche for moms looking for something specific.

11

Heavier Arm Pillow


Itzy Ritzy Milk Boss


Itzy Ritzy Milk Boss
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5


$18.99
(24% off)
at Amazon
See It

Machine Washable: Yes | Belt: No
Helps relieve sore arms
Versatile
Easy to use
Can be awkward
Non-removable cover

The Itzy Ritzy Milk Boss is a versatile arm pillow that works well for bottle or breastfeeding and assists with burping the baby after feeding. The pillow is similar to the Lansinoh Nursie, freeing your lap from a wrap-around design, and the soft cushion helps relieve sore arms from multiple daily feedings. It is easy to use with no buckles or latches to hassle with; stick your arm through the hole, position your baby, and you're ready to go!

While the pillow is user-friendly, it can take several tries to get the best position. The cushion is super supportive but is also very thick, and those with larger breasts or shorter torsos may find that the Milk Boss raises the baby too high for comfortable nursing. The placement can be awkward and take some finagling to figure out as you struggle to adjust the pillow one-handed while holding a baby. Itzy Ritzy does have a helpful video that demonstrates how the pillow works. Also, while the pillow is machine washable, the cover is not removable. Despite the potentially longer learning curve, this might be a good choice for those looking for something different with an increased boost.

Each product in our review was purchased and hands-on tested to...
Each product in our review was purchased and hands-on tested to evaluate multiple factors, including comfort and support.
Credit: Abriah Wofford

Why You Should Trust Us


To find the best nursing pillows, our founder, Dr. Juliet Spurrier, a board-certified pediatrician and mother of two, helps select the competitors from the top-ranked options on the market using her personal experience and feedback from clients on nursing problems or concerns. This roundup also includes Senior Review Editors, Wendy Schmitz (mom of 2) and Abriah Wofford. Having nursed both children for over a year, Wendy brings her personal nursing experience to the table when analyzing each product and the information provided by hands-on testers. With over 10 years of combined experience, either using or testing pillows for nursing, the team brings a level of expertise not found in competing pillow reviews.

We spent months evaluating, researching, and using the nursing pillows. All of the pillows achieve the goal of bringing the baby closer to breast level, but they don't all do it in the same way or with the same level of success. There are several factors to consider when finding a nursing pillow that is right for you and your baby, including ease of use, materials, and ease of cleaning. These 11 pillows were used by real nursing moms who provided feedback on the critical metrics for each pillow testing them side-by-side for a great comparison experience.

Pillow Comparisons
With no hardware to deal with, the cover of the Luna Lullaby Lil...

Analysis


For any new mother, choosing to breastfeed your baby can be gratifying, but it can also be challenging. Therefore, we put mom and baby first when testing and scoring nursing pillows. With nearly 75% of mothers at least attempting to nurse, the number of breastfeeding products is rapidly rising, such as nursing pillows, breast pads, nipple salve, breastmilk supplies, and breast pumps. Nursing can be beautiful, but it isn't without its hurdles. A nursing pillow can provide support and reduce effort so that you can focus on successful nursing. While a pillow for nursing can seem insignificant, it is more involved with various potential options and features designed for nursing success. This review breaks down the differences between top contenders to help you choose the best pillow for you and your baby.

With a wider C-shape, this Boppy provides more support for mom to...
With a wider C-shape, this Boppy provides more support for mom to cradle baby and it's two sided structure allows the pillow to provide unwavering support for baby at any stage of nursing. One negative is that it is almost too plush and tall for women with smaller torsos, as seen here.
Credit: BabyGearLab Staff

Breastfeeding is a Workout


As a new mother, you may not realize how helpful a nursing pillow can be until you begin nursing. Plus, it may seem more like a luxury than a necessity. After all, a regular old pillow already in your home and should work, right? Honestly, for the majority of nursing moms, not so much.

The reality is that breastfeeding a newborn can last up to 40 minutes a session. With an average newborn feeding 8-12 times a day (sometimes, an hour after you just finished your last nursing session), comfort and support for mama are critical. Of course, once your baby gets the hang of things and grows, frequency and duration will somewhat taper, but not significantly until your baby starts eating solids. Also, as your baby grows, you'll have more baby weight to support. In short, breastfeeding is a physical endurance sport for mom, and proper support can be essential to continued success. Without adequate support, you can experience fatigue and pain in the arms, neck, shoulders, wrists, and back. Also, your baby may not be in an optimal nursing position, affecting latch, nipples, and your milk supply. The more negatives you correlate with nursing, the higher chance there is that you'll give up.

The Babymmov Mom and B has microbeads that are easy to adjust to get...
The Babymmov Mom and B has microbeads that are easy to adjust to get baby adjusted to the correct height.
Credit: Abriah Wofford

So, once you realize you'll be breastfeeding your baby about 5-8 hours a day, a nursing pillow becomes more of a necessity and less of a luxury. After all, one of the most significant benefits of nursing is the quality of mommy and baby bonding time that helps you adjust to life together. Without the aid of a suitable nursing pillow, feeding can become difficult, uncomfortable, and frustrating instead of a bonding opportunity.

Nursing typically has a steep learning curve, and it may take weeks to get the hang of effective feeding. A well-made pillow can help support a baby so that mom has full use of her hands to get her breast in the right position to help the baby latch correctly. Mom will also use her arms to support and cradle the baby close. Plus, a pillow will provide mom with a place to rest her arms during nursing, which results in less strain to the neck, shoulders, and back.

My Brest Friend Deluxe offers the same  wrap-around back support of...
My Brest Friend Deluxe offers the same wrap-around back support of the original pillow.
Credit: Micah James

Nursing Pillow Basics


There are various options for pillows designed for nursing, and some have more features than others. However, remember that a nursing pillow has a single purpose of making breastfeeding more comfortable.

Shape


A woman's body will go through a dramatic metamorphosis through pregnancy and postpartum. The various shapes of pillows for nursing suit different body types. We evaluated the following shapes in this review:

An alternative to the C-shaped nursing pillow and O-shaped wrap...
An alternative to the C-shaped nursing pillow and O-shaped wrap around style is a simple, easy to use crescent that the My Blessed Nest (left), Luna Lullaby (center), and Dr. Brown's Gia Angled (right) all use.
Credit: Meg Benedik

  • Crescent Roll — sits in front of the body with little to no wrapping. Examples of this style are the Blessed Nest Organic Nesting and the Luna Lullaby Bosom Baby. The increasingly popular crescent-shaped pillows wrap around a single side of mom's body. The crescent Luna Lullaby Bosom Baby provides extra support in the middle of the cushion where the baby's headrests. This shape can be ideal for curvy women, but it doesn't fit smaller women very well with sides so long they tend to bump against the back of the chair or sofa where mom is sitting. We liked the gently curved shape of the Blessed Nest Organic Nesting Pillow, as it is effortless to adjust with one hand and fits women of different sizes equally well.

  • O-Shaped — wraps around the entire body like the letter "O." This style includes the Twin Z and My Brest Friend Deluxe. The O-design has the advantage of wrapping around the body with cushioned back support and an adjustable waist-belt for a snug fit. This style may not fit all women well, but the pillow will stay with you if you get up to change locations or positions.

Although both Boppy's use a C-shape for their pillow the wider...
Although both Boppy's use a C-shape for their pillow the wider, Boppy Best Latch (right) is able to secure closer to mom's body thanks to its duel buckle system. The straighter edges also provide more arm support for different feeding positions.
Credit: Megan Benedik

  • C-Shaped — are the traditional, wrap-around C-shaped nursing pillows, such as the Boppy Bare Naked. Boppy also has the Boppy Best Latch specifically for nursing with a plush, firm side for newborns and a cushy side for older babies. It includes an adjustable belt but does not have lower back support. This shape tends to fit various body types and provides arm support no matter which side your baby is feeding or which hold you use.

  • Arm Pillow — this type of pillow slides onto your forearm, like the Itzy Ritzy Milk Boss and Lansinoh Nursie. This innovative style works well for moms recovering from a c-section as there is no pillow weight resting on the midsection. It is also great for women of various shapes and sizes as it does not wrap around the body, but it can make your arm sweaty and has a steeper learning curve.

  • Alternative Shapes — The Infantino Elevate does not fit in the traditional categories. This pillow lays flat on your lap, with no wrapping, and although adjustable, it does so in a different way to help you and your baby obtain a comfortable position.

Fit


No matter where you plan to nurse, you'll be sitting up, and your ideal pillow will need to fit your body shape. Your posture is important so you can position the baby's head and body at the height of your nipple. A few nursing pillows offer a buckle strap like the Twin Z or Velcro strap system like the My Brest Friend Deluxe to help achieve a secure and tight fit around the waist. Like the Boppy Best Latch pillow and Luna Lullaby, some pillows are taller, which better suits longer torsos. Other pillows offer a no-frills, simplistic approach designed to wrap around the front and one or both sides of the body. Try to imagine yourself 5-6 months pregnant to help determine which style will fit your midsection best right after birth.

The Babymoov Mom & B fits moms of all shapes and sizes, and is...
The Babymoov Mom & B fits moms of all shapes and sizes, and is great for pregnancy use!
Credit: Abriah Wofford

Fastening Systems


Three of the pillows we tested, My Brest Friend Deluxe, Twin Z, and the Boppy Best Latch, offer a buckle system to help keep the pillow close for the best possible fit. While these features keep the cushion from moving and prevent the baby from slipping between the mom's body and the pillow, they also make it challenging to get the pillow on and off. Typically, feeding time comes with some subtle (or not so subtle) warnings from the baby. When mom struggles to hold a hungry baby with one hand and get the pillow secure with the other, the extra step of buckling will probably go undone.

Thanks to the Velcro strap on the new My Brest Friend Deluxe...
Thanks to the Velcro strap on the new My Brest Friend Deluxe, securing this pillow is no longer a two handed job. Simply, keep the buckle at the desired length, wrap the pillow around your body, and tighten the pillow with the easy to use strap.
Credit: Megan Benedik

Nursing Support and Comfort


A breastfeeding relationship has a greater chance of success if proper technique and great support happen from the very beginning. A good latch is essential to effective and natural breastfeeding. If your nipple or body suffers, everything can quickly spiral out of control resulting in new moms giving up the nursing dream. Using the right pillow can help you focus on a great nursing experience rather than worrying about your comfort or supporting your baby's body.

The travel friendly design of the Luna Lullaby Lil Something makes...
The travel friendly design of the Luna Lullaby Lil Something makes it easy to nurse when out and about.
Credit: Abriah Wofford

The primary reason to have a pillow specifically for nursing is to provide both mother and baby with positional support and comfort.

  • For Mom — Dual arm support, lumbar support, and a snug fit. The baby's mouth needs to be at the same level as the mother's breast. Mom should not be bending or hunched over.

  • For Baby — Head, neck, and body/back support with the baby's nose and mouth positioned level to and facing the mother's nipple. The baby will need to lead with their chin and widely open their mouth to initiate a good latch.

Whether using a nursing pillow from the get-go in the hospital or at home, the extra support can feel like a blessing to an already traumatized post-pregnancy body. Most of your nursing time won't include lounging in an expensive glider; instead, you'll be nursing anywhere you and your baby happen to be, which makes arm support essential.

While feeding on the Boppy Best Latch, baby needs little support to...
While feeding on the Boppy Best Latch, baby needs little support to get in place.
Credit: Michael Benedik

Nursing pillows can provide small infants with a much-needed boost in height, so their head and mouth are at the right position and angle for effective and comfortable feeding. The pillows can also help maintain appropriate positioning for the baby's body during feeding. Early on, keeping the baby's head and bottom horizontal to one other is key. As the baby grows older and stronger, a pillow also needs to be sturdy enough to support more movement during feeding.

Ease of Use


An excellent pillow for nursing should be easy to use without being something a new mother needs to master. Since a baby's hunger typically dictates the nursing location, a mom will need to breastfeed in various locations. As such, the pillow must be portable and easy to store. Extra features that make a mom's job easier, such as pockets for items like burp cloths and nipple salves, are nice. The ease of positioning and removing a pillow is also important for securing straps. We find that buckles like those on the Boppy Best Latch only make a more challenging and cumbersome pillow, especially during nighttime feedings. Last, we consider how each pillow fits during different postpartum experience stages and for women with various body shapes. The Boppy Bare Naked performs well despite its simple design and lack of additional features, it is portable in size and weight, easy to position with one hand, and it fits many women well.

Double latch system on the Best Latch makes it easy for a left or...
The classic "C" shape pillow is easy to use and versatile.

Expected Length of Nursing


Before purchasing a nursing pillow, you may ask, "How long will I nurse my baby?" While your answer may change depending on several factors, having a ballpark idea can be useful. Your pillow's longevity may not matter much if your breastfeeding plans are short. However, if you nurse exclusively at home during your baby's first year, then a more significant pillow investment will make sense.

Nursing Location


Although you may have a fabulous nursing glider, you're likely to find yourself breastfeeding in the family room or kitchen where everyone hangs out. Once your baby hits around 4-months and starts becoming distracted while nursing, your nursing location may shift to a quieter area. Your nursing location (e.g., in a glider, couch, bed, kitchen table, or floor) will likely influence the pillow style you choose.

Taking the Boppy with you, wherever you may nurse, is easy thanks to...
Taking the Boppy with you, wherever you may nurse, is easy thanks to its portable size and easy to clean pillow and case.
Credit: Megan Benedik

A Few to Go Around


When a baby is hungry, but the nursing pillow is in another location, retrieving it can suddenly become a low priority. Sometimes investing in a few and having them dispersed around your favorite nursing spots can make a big difference for its convenience factor.

Portability


Having an easily portable nursing pillow to keep in the car, like the Luna Lullaby Lil Something or Lansinoh Nursie can make a huge difference when nursing away from home.

The Luna Lullaby Lil Something is portable and easy to take with you...
The Luna Lullaby Lil Something is portable and easy to take with you out and about.
Credit: Abriah Wofford

Cover and Pillow Materials


Cushion and cover materials can impact the overall quality, feel, and user experience of the pillow. Our review includes 100% synthetic, 100% cotton, synthetic-cotton blend, and foam products, and some have natural materials like buckwheat hulls and organic cotton. Each material has pros and cons, and it often comes down to personal preference, plus lifestyle to determine which is right for you. However, whenever possible, we lean toward natural products and make an effort to avoid options that can potentially off-gas.

The Nesting Pillow features an organic cover as well as pillow...
The Nesting Pillow features an organic cover as well as pillow filled with organic, pesticide-free buckwheat hulls.
Credit: Megan Benedik

For instance, the Blessed Nest Organic Nesting is an all-natural pillow featuring a 100% organic cotton cover and an interior filling of organic, pesticide-free buckwheat hulls. Although this pillow costs double the price of some of the competition, some parents may feel the additional expense is acceptable for the all-natural materials. However, the Blessed Nest cover doesn't compare to the snuggly softness of polyester covers, like the one found on the Luna Lullaby. Many nursing pillows utilize internal foam for firm support, which is necessary for early infancy, like the My Brest Friend Deluxe. Foam has other concerns, like off-gassing, depending on the type. Fortunately, My Brest Friend no longer uses flame retardants in their foam, and according to the Boppy website, Boppy has never used flame retardants (woohoo!).

Shape Retention


In theory, a nursing pillow should last through the six months of nursing before your baby can fully support him or herself. Ideally, it should continue to be of use through multiple children over multiple years. Our test pillows were in play for nearly four months straight, and each washed a minimum of four times. We analyzed shape retention when we replaced the cover or when a new tester got the pillow. Some contenders look brand new after four months of use, while others grew lumpy, compressed, or misshapen.

Putting the Luna Lullaby pillow back together after cleaning is...
Putting the Luna Lullaby pillow back together after cleaning is trickier than it appears because the pillow changes shape easily.
Credit: Megan Benedik

Cleaning


Trust us, spills and spit-ups are inevitable. So, you'll need to clean your pillow or cover regularly. But, not all products are equal when it comes to the necessary time and effort to get them clean and back in action. With the number of times you need to use your pillow each day, you don't want your pillow out of commission for very long. The best options to clean have covers and pillows that are machine washable and dryer safe, like the Boppy Bare Naked. This design is a huge time-saver. Liquid repelling covers such as the one on the Luna Lullaby also offer quick clean-up. Some pillows have foam inserts that can only be spot cleaned and laid flat to dry (total time suck). While testing, we timed how long it took to put the cover back on each pillow after washing. Although this task should be simple, it took us over ten minutes to put some pillows back together.

The Babymoov Mom and B has a zipper with no tab to pull. We used a...
The Babymoov Mom and B has a zipper with no tab to pull. We used a safety pin to remove the cover when needed.
Credit: Abriah Wofford

Value


When it comes to finding an excellent pillow for nursing, we encourage you to think about how often you'll use it. Since you'll be using the pillow multiple times every day, a more expensive option will quickly break down to pennies for each use. Also, most products will likely last through multiple babies, making it a piece of gear that you can use for years. Pillows can also be used for comfort, propping up older babies, and for dad's helping with feeding. The Bobby Bare Naked and Luna Lullaby Lil Something pillows are both budget-conscious choices, with the Boppy having lived through multiple children and years of heavy use. The Blessed Nest Organic Nesting is also a good value despite the higher list price because it provides organic and natural materials for sensitive moms or babies in addition to a versatile shape. Even if you only use it for the first year, it will be one of the least expensive gear items in your nursery, and it will make your life easier (hard to put a price on that). We believe that the price of a good nursing style pillow is worth the advantages of having a pillow specifically designed for nursing.

The Luna Lullaby Lil Something is a great value and is a comfortable...
The Luna Lullaby Lil Something is a great value and is a comfortable spot for baby even when you are not nursing.
Credit: Abriah Wofford

Conclusion


Motherhood is an emotion-filled ride, full of learning, as well as trial and error. Whether you choose to breastfeed or bottle-feed, babies often eat for longer than you ever thought possible. With some feeding sessions lasting upwards of 40 minutes, we think you'll appreciate having a properly supportive accessory by your side. For this purpose, a nursing pillow can be essential, providing the physical support needed to feed your baby. Let us guide you through the details and specifics, so you are equipped to make the right choice for you and your brand new little one.

Juliet Spurrier, MD, Wendy Schmitz, and BabyGearLab Review Team