Graco 4Ever DLX Review

Graco Metal Products decided to make new products in 1953 after hiring an engineer to create new designs. With inspiration from an outdoor glider, Rex Thomas and David Saint designed the first swing for babies. The first of its kind sold millions pushing Graco into the baby gear stratosphere. Graco continues to create baby-centric products, including swings, walkers, car seats, strollers, and more.

Performance Comparison

The headrest and harness height adjustment assembly on the 4Ever has dense impact foam.

Credit: Abriah Wofford

Crash Test

The 4ever has a higher than average crash test analysis result with sensor data significantly better than that allowed by the federal guidelines. All the products in this review meet or exceed the federal minimum safety guidelines defined in the FMVSS 213. This Graco has better than average results overall, with respectable results for both the HIC and chest sensors. Both sensors recorded G forces well below the maximum allowed. We commission crash tests with the same facility National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) uses and to the same specifications. In our opinion, the test data indicates that this Graco provides an additional margin of protection over many of the competitors in this review.

The charts below show the crash test results from the chest sensors used in the Graco tests (shown in black). The crash test data for the Clek Foonf (in green) is also shown as a comparison with the least amount of G-forces. The 4ever earned a 43 where the maximum allowed is 60, and the best in the group is 33.

The 4Ever has a better than average clip score but it isn't good enough to keep up with the competition.

Credit: BabyGearLab, MGA Research

The 4Ever's HIC score struggles to compete with the best in the group, the Britax Allegiance.

Credit: BabyGearLab, MGA Research

The Graco HIC result is 364 compared to the best result of 186 earned by the Britax Allegiance. The lower the number, the better for these tests, and the maximum allowable result is 1000.

INstallation of the 4Ever isn't great no matter which option you choose.

Credit: Abriah Wofford

Ease of Install - LATCH

Installation using LATCH isn't challenging, but it isn't as easy and much for the competition turning in a below-average performance in our tests.

The LATCH connectors on the 4Ever are the push-button type we feel are easier to operate over the clip style.

Credit: Abriah Wofford

The connectors are the push-button style we prefer and are easy enough to clip in place and remove, but threading the straps is a pain and is a process required no matter what installation process you choose. The holes seem way too small and can be a pain if your hands are larger. Rear-facing is easier than forward-facing, but it is still challenging to keep all the padding and straps out of the way to complete the installation.

This seat comes with a bubble level indicator (above left), which is easy to read, and the angle of the seat can be moved for comfort (above right).

Installing the 4Ever isn't as easy as it should be whether you choose LATCH or the vehicle belt.

Credit: Abriah Wofford

Ease of Install - Belt

Installing using the vehicle belt is so similar to the LATCH connection that it is similar in difficulty, with both methods earning the same results. Forward-facing is more difficult than rear-facing, as the harness straps and the comfort padding of the seat need to be held aside to access the belt lock-off and belt path. Rear-facing is easier but still presents the same challenges as the LATCH connection.

Raising the headrest gives better access to the "behind the scenes" operations so you can both see more and fit your hands in easier. The belt lock-off (above left) and pathway are both behind the seatback padding, but the entire process would be easier if the holes (above right) were larger.

The 4Ever has cup holders which might be useful for older children's snacks, but the narrow width makes them somewhat useless for many sippy cups.

Credit: Abriah Wofford

Ease of Use

This Graco has a better than average performance for ease of use, but it pales compared to the competition in its price range. It does have child cup holders, which is not common in our review, though their usefulness is debatable.

The buckle and chest clip on the 4Ever aren't as intuitive as they should be.

Credit: Abriah Wofford

Harness

The 4Ever has an average buckle and chest clip; both work but are somewhat stiff and less intuitive than the competition. The harness can be tightened by pulling the strap at the seat's foot, and a lever under the fabric flap above the strap will let you loosen the strap. The lever can be pushed or pulled and isn't too deep under the flap.

The headrest assembly on the 4Ever is easy to raise and lower with 10 positions possible to change harness height levels with ease.

Credit: Abriah Wofford

The shoulder height adjustment for this harness is a non-rethread method where the headrest assembly moves up and down to change the height of the shoulder straps. The adjustment is super easy and moves smoothly up and down when you squeeze the lever on top. This process can be done with your child in the seat.

LATCH and Manual Storage

LATCH connectors can clip under the front of the seat (above left) when not in use, and they are easy to access and do a good job keeping the straps out of the way. The user manual stows under the seat's base (above right) in a designated location that looks like it will keep it secure and fairly clean.

Cover

The cover of this seat is machine washable but needs to be hung to dry. Machines washable is a best-case scenario, and we applaud any seat that makes life easier. We think hanging to dry could be a problem as this takes time and, depending on your climate, could cause a problem with potential seat use. Removing and replacing the cover is fairly straightforward, but threading the loops is hard.

The quality of this Graco is on par with other Graco options, but its higher price means we expected more.

Credit: Abriah Wofford

Comfort/Quality

The 4Ever doesn't have the best quality, and while this may be par for the course for the budget-friendly brand, this option has a fairly high price for the quality level it's offering. It simply can't compete with the padding, fabric, and overall attention to detail found in the similarly priced competition.

The backside of the 4Ever is relatively open and has nooks and crannies that can make keeping it clean a challenge compared to options that have smooth backs.

Credit: Abriah Wofford

The padding is adequate but could be denser for comfort, and the fabric has a relatively cares weave with piping details that could chafe the bare skin of passengers. The shell is only semi-contained, and there are plenty of nooks and crannies on the whole seat that will make cleaning challenging. The base bottom is smooth to protect your vehicle seat, which is a nice detail, but overall it feels more like a less expensive seat.

The 4Ever is wide at over 19 inches but it is one of the lighter options in the review at slightly over 21 lbs.

Credit: Abriah Wofford

Weight

The 4Ever is one of the widest seats in the group, with a width of 19.3 inches, making it unlikely for use with multiple safety seats in a row or if you want an adult to sit between two seats. It weighs somewhat below the average, with an overall weight of over 21 lbs. While not the heaviest in the group, over 30 lbs, it isn't one you'd want to carry for travel, carpooling or public transportation. However, there are only a handful of options lighter in this review.

Should You Buy the Graco 4Ever DLX ?

We don't think so. This car seat didn't score very well compared to the competition, and we think there are several more compelling options in this review, including Graco and other brand seats. The 4Ever might be attractive as a one-and-done option, but we encourage parents to avoid this kind of seat and instead focus on buying a specific seat for each stage of life, including and infant car seat, convertible seat, and booster seat. We do not think this is a time to save money or time with your purchase.

What Other Convertible Car Seat Should You Consider?

If Graco floats your boat, you're in luck. The Graco Extend2Fit is less expensive than the 4Ever, and it has some of the best crash test results in the group. The Extend2Fit also works for an extended time up to 50 lbs instead of 40, and it is lighter weight. Both Graco's ear the same score for ease of installation.

Manufacturer Video