The Crocodile Creek bottle ranked 10th out of 11 bottles in this review. It is sort of a cool cup on the surface and we sort of had high hopes for it, but in the end it just failed to measure up to the competition and it had some relatively significant problems that prevented it from scoring higher. While it has some attributes we really like, a stainless steel body and attached lid, it struggled in some basic areas of performance like preventing leaks and being easy to use. In the end it is a bottle we can't recommend, but still feel sort of badly about that fact.
Crocodile Creek Drinking Bottle Review
Pros: Super fun graphics, stainless steel body, attached lid, lightweight
Cons: Leaked, hard to drink from, not insulated
Manufacturer: Crocodile Creek
Our Analysis and Test Results
The Crocodile Creek kid's bottle is an eco-friendly, stainless steel bottle. It is made with #304 stainless steel that is lead safe, and phthalate and BPA free. It holds 13.5 ounces of liquid and is recommended for ages 3 years and up. The bottle has an easy to use plastic lid that helps keep the drinking spout clean. Some of the bottles come in a variety of bright and colorful patterns, and therefore they should be hand washed. This bottle is 100% recyclable, has a slim design, and fits in most cup holders.
We like that his bottle is made of food grade stainless steel and is electropolished so it is easy to clean and doesn't have any edges for gunk to collect. We prefer steel to plastic because it is an inert material that doesn't leach or impart flavor to its contents.
This bottle has a narrow slim design and is lightweight compared to the other stainless steel options in this review. This made the bottle easier to pick up and hold for little hands, and it scored well in this metric. It also comes with an attached lid to keep the mouthpiece free of dirt and debris.
This bottle leaked; it received the second lowest collective score in our tests for leaking. It leaked upside down and sideways with the lid off and spout open. While it might prevent leaks better with the spout closed and the lid on,
This bottle is also hard to drink from. The sport type spout doesn't have a regular flow rate and some children had difficulty drinking without closing the spout at the same time when they pressed it to their lips. In general, it seemed more difficult that should be necessary for a kids bottle, and over time the frustration grew for some kids, resulting in the lack of use of the bottle.Even thought this bottle has a small number of parts, the mouthpiece design is a little bit of a challenge to clean properly, and we found it was best to use a straw brush to get in the crevices even though it doesn't actually have a straw. we also sort of wish the mouthpiece didn't require that little hands to open it for use, this potentially creates a dirty spout for drinking that was clean prior to being pulled open.
This is such a fun looking stainless steel bottle that we really wanted to like it, and most of the in-house little testers did like it. It brings together some of the attributes we find favorable when looking for possible water bottles for kids. It is eco-healthy, has a nice lid, and isn't too expensive. Unfortunately the excessive leaking and the hard to use spout make it a bottle that failed to meet our expectations and didn't match the competition in testing. This makes the Crocodile a bottle we don't recommend, even if we say that with a bit of a heavy heart.
— Juliet Spurrier, MD & Wendy Schmitz