In-depth reviews guided by a Pediatrician

AVENT Natural Comfort Manual Review

This pump gets the job done but with a few drawbacks including efficiency, comfort and hygiene.
AVENT Natural Comfort Manual
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Price:   $45 List | $26 at Amazon
Pros:  lightweight, portable
Cons:  uncomfortable, difficult to clean, inefficient
Manufacturer:   Philips Avent
By Lindsay Smith and Curtis Smith  ⋅  Mar 4, 2014
  • Share this article:
Our Editors independently research, test, and rate the best products. We only make money if you purchase a product through our links, and we never accept free products from manufacturers. Learn more
62
OVERALL
SCORE


RANKED
#5 of 10
  • Efficiency - 30% 6
  • Comfort - 20% 5
  • Ease of Use - 25% 7
  • Portability - 10% 8
  • Hygiene - 10% 4
  • Accoustics - 5% 9

The Skinny

The AVENT Natural Comfort Manual is a single breast pump offered by Philips, a tried and true company that many have come to trust. This pump does its job, but it wasn't our favorite manual pump for many reasons. The efficiency, comfort and hygiene left something to be desired, especially compared to the similarly functioning (and our Top Pick Award winner), the Medela Harmony Manual.


Compare to Similar Products

 
Awards  Editors' Choice Award Best Value Award Top Pick Award  
Price $44.99 List
$25.92 at Amazon - 42% off
$200.00 List
$198.99 at Amazon
$300.00 List
$199.99 at Amazon - 33% off
$42.00 List
$28.44 at Amazon - 32% off
$200.00 List
Overall Score Sort Icon
100
0
62
100
0
91
100
0
80
100
0
74
100
0
65
Star Rating
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Pros lightweight, portableEfficient, comfortable, portable, fashionable, easy to use, quiet, hygienic, good customer serviceGood value, efficient, portable, easy to use, great accessoriessmall, lightweight, portable, comfortable, efficient, easy to use, quietportable, hygienic, quiet, easy to use
Cons uncomfortable, difficult to clean, inefficientExpensive, only one bottle holder, incompatible with pumping bracondensation in tubing, loudsingle breast pump, hand operated, not for frequent useuncomfortable, inefficient
Bottom Line This pump gets the job done but with a few drawbacks including efficiency, comfort and hygiene.A little expensive but worth it for superior quality, efficiency, hygiene, quiet sound, comfort and style.Great pump with the most accessories for the best priceA great pump for traveling moms or moms who don't plan on pumping oftenA good pump that does the job and is easy to use but is lacking in comfort and efficiency.
Rating Categories AVENT Natural... S1 Hospital Grade Medela Pump In... Medela Harmony... AVENT Comfort...
Efficiency (30%)
10
0
6
10
0
9
10
0
8
10
0
7
10
0
6
Comfort (20%)
10
0
5
10
0
9
10
0
7
10
0
10
10
0
4
Ease Of Use (25%)
10
0
7
10
0
9
10
0
10
10
0
5
10
0
8
Portability (10%)
10
0
8
10
0
8
10
0
10
10
0
8
10
0
8
Hygiene (10%)
10
0
4
10
0
10
10
0
4
10
0
7
10
0
7
Accoustics (5%)
10
0
9
10
0
10
10
0
5
10
0
10
10
0
7
Specs AVENT Natural... S1 Hospital Grade Medela Pump In... Medela Harmony... AVENT Comfort...
Weight 7oz 5 lbs 10 oz 6 lbs 3 oz 6 oz 2 lbs 12 oz
Pump Dimensions 6.75 x 3.5W x 5.25D 7.25H x 6.5W x 8D 4.25H x 4.75W x 5.5D 7H x 2.25W x 7.5D 4H x 5.25W x 2.75D
Closed vs Open System open closed open open Closed
Double, Single, or Both single Double Double single Double
Digital controls no yes no no yes
Adjustable Speed yes-manual yes yes yes- manual yes
Adjustable Suction no yes yes no yes
Maximum Suction Strength manual 0-300 (per manufacturer) unable to test manual unable to test
2-Phase Expression no no yes yes yes
Flange Sizes no no yes-must purchase separately can purchase different sizes no
AC Adapter no rechargeable battery and ac adapter yes no ac adapter
Battery Details manual rechargeable battery 8AA batteries/rechargeable battery pack not included manual no
Battery Duration manual dry run: 4 hr, 33 min dry run: 6+ hours manual only ac adapter
Bottle Holder/Stand yes yes yes yes yes
Included Accessories one bottle with lid, bottle nipple and bottle cover, pump, rubber inlay for breast flange, disk to cover breast flange Pump, 2 breastshields, 2 bottles, 2 bottle nipples, pump tubing, 2 bottle stands, 2 disks, 2 caps,2 back flow filters, 2 valves pump, tote bag, 4 bottles with lids, ice pack, two breast flanges, 9-volt ac adapter, battery pack 2 bottles with lids, bottle stand, pump pump, 2 bottles, 2 bottle lids, 2 bottle nipples, 2 sealing disks, tote bag, 20 disposable day breast pads, 20 disposable night breast pads, travel pouch for accessories (not insulated), breastfeeding bra clip
Miscellaneous Details both nightlight and timer pump built into tote bag, cannot be removed buttons light up

Our Analysis and Test Results

Philips is a very large company with a subset of breast pumps as well as other products available. This manual pump received a lot of positive reviews from moms on various websites, citing very few negatives. Overall we agree, as we found this to be a very efficient manual pump. Although it didn't score quite as high as our Top Pick Medela Harmony Manual pump, it was a close second. Read on to find out why.

Performance Comparison


A view of the breast pump with its protective cap designed to keep it clean during transport.
A view of the breast pump with its protective cap designed to keep it clean during transport.

Efficiency


We scored this pump at a 6/10 for efficiency. Once the pump is lined up correctly on your breast, it expresses a good amount of milk in a reasonable time. We did notice a slight draw back to its efficiency would be the rubber inlay. Many moms appreciate this rubber inlay on the breast flange for comfort, but when it comes to efficiency it has a couple of problems. Mainly it leaves less room for your breast which can cause your breast to be pulled sideways if it is not lined up properly. This often takes a couple of tries to correct.

Comfort


The rubber flange insert that might make pumping more comfortable for some  but for us  that wasn't the case.
The rubber flange insert that might make pumping more comfortable for some, but for us, that wasn't the case.
This pump scored a 5/10 for comfort. We scored this pump low on comfort due to the rubber inlay. While for some moms, it seems this is an aide to make pumping more comfortable, for others it seems to make pumping very uncomfortable. It's difficult to recommend this pump when there is such a split opinion on comfort, but for us, it just wasn't comfortable at all. It was the same problem we encountered with the AVENT Comfort Double Electric Pump in that if your breasts aren't lined up correctly, it creates what one of our testers called a "tittie twister event" which trust us, no mom wants! We found it more comfortable to take the rubber inlay out and pump with just the plastic flange. Of course this all depends on breast size, nipple size, etc…

Ease of use


We gave this pump a 7/10 for ease of use. All of the manual pumps are very easy to use with the exception of the work it requires from your hand. This pump requires you to empty each breast separately while using your opposing hand to work the pumping lever. We found the lever on this pump to be a little more labor intensive than that of the Medela Manual pump. Its the lever angle that is a little more harsh which requires a little more work from your hand.

Portability


Loaded up and ready to go.  The bag has a nice sturdy structure but also fairly tight quarters.
Loaded up and ready to go. The bag has a nice sturdy structure but also fairly tight quarters.
As with most of the manual pumps we tested, this pump scored well on portability. All the manual pumps are very portable, and can fit easily in your purse or a carry on bag for a flight. However, it doesn't come with a tote bag or insulated bag to store your milk in. It does come with one extra bottle so you can store up to 10 ounces of milk in a refrigerator without needing any other storage solutions for expressed milk.

Hygiene


This pump received a pretty low score for hygiene. It was difficult to pull each section apart and clean all the crevasses completely without finding dried up milk on the next pumping session. This is mainly due to the rubber inlay that creates the suction on the pump adapter.

Acoustics


This manual pump works quietly with a simple squeeze and release operation.
This manual pump works quietly with a simple squeeze and release operation.
This pump scored great on acoustics. All of the manual pumps are virtually silent, baring the sound of the lever actually moving to pump. This pump scored just behind the Medela Harmony Manual in the manual pump section for acoustics. It is a great, discrete way to pump especially if you are on a plane or in a public place that does not offer a lot of privacy.

Best Applications


This pump is best suited for a mom who plans on pumping less than once a week or as a companion pump for a mom who is planning a vacation or two during her time still breastfeeding or pumping. On a vacation, we'd still only recommend using it to provide a date night stash. Anything more than that you may want to check your double electric pump at the gate.

Value


The AVENT Natural Comfort Manual retails as the most expensive manual breast pump we tested, coming in around $45 list price. You can occassionally find better deals on it at various online retailers, but those sale prices are still usually more expensive than the other two manual pumps we tested. This pump is a good pump, but not comparable to the lower priced Medela Harmony Manual.


Conclusion


This is a good, portable, easy to use manual pump. It would be sufficient for your needs if you don't pump that often or are planning a trip or a date night. As stated, the rubber inlays in the breast flanges can be either a positive or a negative, as some moms seem to love them but we found them to be uncomfortable and to decrease our efficiency.

Video




Lindsay Smith and Curtis Smith