 This Product
SNOO Smart Sleeper | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Awards |  Best Overall Bassinet | Quality Co-Sleeper at a Premium Price |  Budget-Friendly Co-Sleeper | Ideal for Post-Cesarean Section Moms | |
| Price | $1,695 List $1,187 at Amazon | $220 List | $290 List | $220 List $134.99 at Amazon | $220 List $215.00 at Amazon |
Overall Score  |
|||||
| Star Rating | |||||
| Bottom Line | Innovative and seems to help soothe, but we feel the EMF exposure is a no-go for us | Good choice for co-sleeping that is easy to move from room to room | Functional wood bassinet you can use from your bed | Good for co-sleeping and a free-standing bassinet for most families | Safer alternative to co-sleeping and perfect for moms with c-sections |
| Rating Categories | SNOO Smart Sleeper | Arm's Reach Clear-V... | babybay Bedside Sle... | Baby Delight Beside... | HALO BassiNest Esse... |
| Ease of Use (35%) | |||||
| Breathability (25%) | |||||
| Sleep Surface (20%) | |||||
| Quality (15%) | |||||
| Eco-Health (5%) | |||||
| Specs | SNOO Smart Sleeper | Arm's Reach Clear-V... | babybay Bedside Sle... | Baby Delight Beside... | HALO BassiNest Esse... |
| Assembled Weight | 35.1 lbs | 22.1 lbs | 28.6 lbs | 17.5 lbs | 33 lbs |
| Open Dimensions | 31"H x 35.5"L x 20"W | 34.8"H x 34.5"L x 20.3"W | 37.1"H x 36"L x 20.7"W | 26"-30.5"H x 39"L x 27"W | 36.9"H x 45.3"L (base) 33.8" (bassinet) x 21.8"W (bassinet) |
| Age/Height/Weight Limit | 6 Months or 25 lbs Discontinue Use When Infant: Pushes Up On Hands And Knees |
5 Months or 18 lbs Discontinue Use When Infant: Pushes Up On Hands And Knees |
5 Months Discontinue Use When Infant: Pushes Up On Hands And Knees Discontinue As An Attachable Baby Bed When Infant: Rolls Over Or Pulls Up To A Kneeling, Sitting Or Standing Position |
5 Months or 20 lbs Discontinue Use When Infant: Pushes Up On Hands And Knees |
5 Months or 20 lbs Discontinue Use When Infant: Pushes Up On Hands And Knees, Pulls Up, Rolls Over, Sit Unassisted, Can Move Out Of The Security Of The Walled Sleep Area |
| Product Care | Sleep Sack, Sheet: Machine Wash, Tumble Dry Mattress: Spot Clean |
Mattress: Wipe Clean Mattress Sheet: Machine Wash Metal Frame: Wipe Clean Lining: Machine Wash |
Wipe Down | Machine Wash | Sheet: Machine Wash Base and Mattress: Spot Clean |
| Bassinet Mattress Height Above Floor | 22" | 19.5"-25.5" Adult Mattress Height 24"-30" |
3"-27" Adult Mattress Height 10"-31" |
14" - 19" Adult Mattress Height 18.5"-24" |
26.5"-33" |
| Special Features | SNOO Sack Attaches To Safety Clips, 3 White-Noise Sounds, Rocks Baby When Baby Cries, Adjustable Settings, Mobile App For Alerts, Reports and Settings, Ambient Light Sensor | Adjustable Legs | Made From Solid Wood | Foldable | Rotates 360 Degrees, Sidewall Lowers |
| Modes | Bassinet | Bassinet Bedside Sleeper |
Bedside Sleeper | Bedside Sleeper Bassinet |
Bassinet Bedside Sleeper |
| Chemical Flame Retardant Free | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Portable Design | No | No | No | Yes | No |
| Wheels | No | Yes | No | Yes | No |
| Mesh Sides | Yes - Full | Partial - Fabric in Corners | Wood Slats | Yes - Full | Yes - Full |
| Included Accessories | Snoo Sacks (Small, Medium, Large), Fitted Sheet | Fitted Sheet | None | Sheet | Fitted Sheet |
| Available Accessories | Snoo Sack, SNOO Smart Sleeper 100% Organic Cotton Fitted Sheet, SNOO Leg Lifters (2-pack), SNOO Shorty Legs | Arm's Reach® Clear-Vue™ Au Naturel Mattress Pad, Puppy Luv Music Box, Replacement Strap and Plate | Classic Mattress, Cooling Comfort Mattress, Eco-Organic Mattress, Cloud Comfort Mattress, Cooling Comfort Jersey Sheet, Snuggle Comfort Terry Sheet, Dry Comfort Mattress Protector, Classic Comfort Mattress Pad with Cotton Cover, Cooling Comfort Mattress Pad with Dry Comfort Mattress Protector, Organic Comfort Mattress Pad with Dry Comfort Mattress Protector, Cloud Comfort Mattress Pad with Dry Comfort Mattress Protector, babybay Organic Babynest, babybay Patterned Babynest, babybay Solid Colored Babynest, Bassinet Conversion Kit, Rolling Casters, Canopy Holder, Organic Canopy, Patterned Canopy, Solid Colored Canopy, Bed Frame Anchor, babycare Organizer | Waterproof Fitted Sheet | Fitted Sheet, Mattress Pad, Mobile Sleepy Owl, Mobile Whimsical Birds, Storage Caddy, Newborn Insert |
| Set Up Time | 29:20 (58:34 total with redo) | 39:14 | 6:50 | 27:10 | |
| Materials | Sleep Sacks: GOTS certified organic cotton and polyester mesh Fitted Sheet: 100% Organic Cotton Mattress Cover: Polyester, Polyurethane Mesh: Nylon, Polyester |
Strong Nylon Cloth, Cotton Polyester Blend, Nylon Woven Strapping, Polyurethane Foam | Beechwood, Water-Based Finishes, CFC Polyurethane Foam | Polyester, Polyester Fiber Batting | Polyester Fiber, Polyester Fiber Batting, Polyurethane Foam |
The SNOO Smart Sleeper is an innovative bassinet designed by the author of the Happiest Baby On the Block Book, Dr. Harvey Karp, and his wife, Nina Karp. It is based upon the principle of the Five S's and uses swaddling, swaying, and shushing (white noise) to soothe babies in this bassinet. Dr. Karp also offers a variety of DVDs and books designed to help parents better understand and navigate a newborn's (as well as toddler's) fussiness, sleep, and developmental issues. He is a well-loved and highly respected member of the pediatric community.
The SNOO recently started a subscription service through their app. This service is required if you hope to use all of the features and functionality. If you buy Snoo from the company, you get nine months of free service. However, if you buy it used or plan to use it with a second baby, you will need to sign up for the subscription and pay a monthly fee to use all the features. We are not big fans of subscription services, especially those attached to a product that is already so expensive. Additionally, they sprung this change on customers who bought products before the change and then lost certain functionalities of their Snoo. We think this decision to move to a subscription service model is a big bummer and could inhibit your ability to sell your Snoo when your baby days are over. The website doesn't say how much it costs, but the rumors are $20 a month. Here are the features you lose if you choose not to buy the premium subscription:
The SNOO Smart Sleeper had an average ease-of-use score. While it can make your life easier thanks to the unique features it offers, it is significantly more involved than your average bassinet and may have more of a learning curve in the beginning, should you choose to use it with your smartphone.
Below we delve into ease of use specifics of accessibility, portability/mobility, additional features, ease of setup, and cleaning.
The legs included with the SNOO are not adjustable, so the bassinet height cannot be changed to match the height of your mattress unless you purchase a different set of legs. The level of the baby sleep surface is a few inches lower than your average 25" bed, while the upper rail reaches a few inches higher. This design means you'll need to reach up and over the top edge and then below waist level to get your baby without leaving your bed. If this sounds uncomfortable, that's because it probably is. So, while it is possible to reach the baby without getting out of bed, we think you'll find it easier to swing your legs over the bed edge to give the whole operation a bit more stability.
The SNOO is not very portable. At 35.1 lbs, it is the heaviest bassinet in this review, and it does not fold down or come apart for smoother transportation. It is not very large, so it can easily fit through door frames and hallways, but the weight may deter you from moving it from room to room.
This “Smart Sleeper” has a strong emphasis on the additional features it offers with the most extras by far of all the bassinets in this review. Perhaps the most notable is the soothing ability of the “wiggly” mattress. A microphone located in the base of the SNOO detects crying and then tells the motor to start working through four increasingly vigorous levels of rocking to soothe the baby. The speaker system automatically chooses one of four levels of white noise. If your baby has not calmed down after three minutes, the SNOO shuts off, as the baby likely needs some human attention. If you prefer to adjust rocking speed and noise level on your own, you can do this through the app. The SNOO app also logs your baby's sleep and keeps track of things like day sleep, night sleep, total sleep, the longest stretch of sleep, and the number of times the baby woke up while in the SNOO.
Included with the bassinet are one fitted sheet and three swaddle sizes. The swaddles work specifically with the SNOO. They have tabs that slide over hooks on either side of the bassinet. These keep baby in the center of the mattress and always on their back. The SNOO will not function with swaying and shushing unless you properly clip the swaddle into the hook. We recommend purchasing an additional sack in each size for cleaning purposes in the event of leaking accidents or spit-up.
The setup process for the SNOO is one of the easiest in the group. Straight out of the box, the bassinet calls for minimal assembly and zero toolage. The initial setup involves very few steps of snapping in the legs and hand tightening the bolts that keep it sturdy. The only possible mix up that we foresee is inserting the legs backward. This mistake doesn't affect the functionality of the bassinet, but it looks strange. After assembly, you only need to plug it in and secure the sleep sack for day-to-day use.
Both the sheets and sleep sacks that come with the SNOO are machine-washable. Other items in the sleeping area, such as the mattress, mesh sides, and base, can be wiped or spot cleaned with a damp cloth and mild detergent when necessary. The support beneath the mattress is hard plastic and is easy to wipe down, but you may have a bit more trouble with the mesh sidewalls should they become soiled.
The SNOO was one of the top scorers for breathability, impressing us with the thought that went into making this a safe sleep space for baby.
The sidewalls are breathable double-layered mesh fabric that allows for good airflow around the bassinet. Thanks to the clip-in swaddle, the baby is held securely in place, eliminating the chance of a baby rolling or wriggling themselves up against the side.
We were pleased with the SNOO's sleep surface, and it earned one of the higher scores in this metric.
The mattress is very stable and fits well in the bassinet. It shifts slightly from top to bottom, but there wasn't enough room for us to squeeze more than one finger between the mattress and the side mesh. It is not attached to the base in any way, but after clipping in baby with the sleep sack, it should stay in place well. We found the surface to be the third most firm of the group, being surpassed only by the UPPAbaby Bassinet and Stand and the HALO Bassinest Essentia. Our one issue with the SNOO's bassinet mattress is that it is composed of polyurethane, which at this high price point, we'd love to see a lower VOC type material used, such as polyethylene. Perhaps in SNOO V2?
The SNOO earned a great score for quality, coming in alongside a few other top products. For a bassinet in this price range, we would expect no less.
The four legs come out from the bassinet and have rubberized foot pads that make it extremely stable. The low center of gravity and the substantial weight of the SNOO also help to eliminate the risk of tipping. All odds and ends are tucked away for a simple and stylish, mid-century modern look, and there are no sharp edges, pinch risks, small parts, or a mattress gap to cause worry. The fabric and mesh are snug and fitted, and the other materials have a smooth assembly for a great fit and finish. The mattress adheres to ASTM standards and is still comfortable enough for baby.
The SNOO is a well-build bassinet that should last through multiple children. We think of it more as a long-term investment should you desire to welcome further babes into your family in the years to come.
The SNOO earned a score that is just above average for the group.
It is clear that on the Happiest Baby website, sleep safety is the top priority, but there is little information on the eco-health of the Smart Sleeper. After some digging around, we found that the bassinet is JPMA certified, both the sheets and the swaddles are GOTS certified organic materials, and it contains no detectable levels of fire retardant chemicals. However, it does have a polyurethane foam mattress, just like every one of the bassinets in this review, which aren't ideal for developing babies due to off-gassing VOCs. We feel that at this high price point, more inert material should be used, such as polyethylene, to limit this potential risk. The crib mattress market is already beginning to swing away from polyurethane, and we'd like to see the travel crib market do the same. We realize that with a much lower width of 1" to contend with that, this is a different matter to consider from crib mattresses. However, our opinion that this is the correct direction in which to lead.
Unlike any other bassinet, this unit uses WiFi technology to talk with your smartphone or tablet to set up or modify how the SNOO operates. As a result, it emits EMF, to which your baby is then exposed. Some studies indicate that exposure to EMF (prolonged or continuous) can potentially cause long-term health problems down the road. During testing, we got readings of 4.4 V/m on average next to the power button. When using the meter inside the bassinet where the baby will sleep, levels are somewhat lower, with an average reading of 2.35 V/m. This slightly lower reading is likely a result of the manufacturer's design that has a shield plate between the baby and the EMF source, indicating SNOO manufacturers are also aware of the EMF issue. But, our feeling is that the EMF shielding on the SNOO is insufficient.
The level of EMF we measured is almost as concerning as we measured on some of the wearable movement monitors. If you are trying to limit your baby's EMF exposure (which we think parents should), we consider the SNOO is a product to avoid. The EMF levels give us pause and make the SNOO a bassinet we wouldn't feel comfortable recommending to a friend. Because your baby can sleep in almost any other product without the risk of EMF exposure, it is hard for us to say we feel comfortable with newborns being exposed to EMF when they don't need to be.
We would love this product if there were a way to use it without EMF involvement like a simple on/off switch for the WiFi radio. Why has Dr. Karp allowed his otherwise compelling product to use a design that forces parents to accept exposing their baby to significant levels of EMF? We feel this is a product design failure, and we hope this is something Dr. Karp and the folks at Happiest Baby will address in future versions so parents concerned with EMF have the option to soothe their baby using the SNOO.
