Motorola HALO Review
Pros: Ok video, easier to use, included parent device
Cons: WiFi required, poor sound quality, expensive
Compare to Similar Products
$289.99 at Amazon
$129.99 at Amazon
|Check Price at Amazon||$300 List|
$249.99 at Amazon
$179.99 at Amazon
|Pros||Ok video, easier to use, included parent device||Internet range, great images, versatile long term use||Good visuals, lots of features, easy to use||Easy to use, WiFi range, lower EMF||WiFi range, lots of features, great images, easy to use|
|Cons||WiFi required, poor sound quality, expensive||No internet / no monitor, disappointing sound||Sound could be better, harder setup||Sub-par sound, expensive||Sub par sound, higher price, internet dependant|
|Bottom Line||Disappointing sound and a higher price make it hard to justify this lower ranking option||Really cool WiFi camera with lots of uses and great video for simple baby monitoring||Good for long term use if you already own other Arlo products||A relatively expensive option that is easy to use and has many features with lower EMF||Cool WiFi option with all the bells and whistles that is easy to use|
|Rating Categories||Motorola HALO||Nest Cam Indoor WiFi||Arlo Baby||Nanit Pro||iBaby Care M7 WiFi|
|Sound Clarity (20%)|
|Video Quality (30%)|
|Ease Of Use (15%)|
|Battery Life (10%)|
|Specs||Motorola HALO||Nest Cam Indoor WiFi||Arlo Baby||Nanit Pro||iBaby Care M7 WiFi|
|Communication Technology||802.11b/g/n @ 2.4GHz||802.11 a/b/g/n||2.4 GHz||2.4GHz and 5GHz||802.11 b/g/n|
|Indoor Range Test||Anywhere You Have Connectivity||Anywhere You Have Connectivity||Anywhere You Have Connectivity||Anywhere You Have Connectivity||Anywhere You Have Connectivity|
|Open Field Range Test||Anywhere You Have Connectivity||Anywhere You Have Connectivity||Anywhere You Have Connectivity||Anywhere You Have Connectivity||Anywhere You Have Connectivity|
|Manufacturer's Claimed Range (*buyer beware!)||Anywhere You Have Connectivity||Anywhere You Have Connectivity||Anywhere You Have Connectivity||Anywhere You Have Connectivity||Anywhere You Have Connectivity|
|Max Sound||86 db||86 db||93 db||89 db||82 db|
|Max # of Cameras||1||10 Per Home with Unlimited Homes||5 simultaneous video streams free.
Up to 20 cameras with paid subscription.
|Up to 5. If you plan to use more than 5 cameras contact customer support||Not Listed (Unlimited?)|
|EMF @ 6 Feet from Camera||2.5 V/m||0.92 V/m||0.75 V/m||0.37 V/m||1.42 V/m|
|Warranty||1 Year||2 Year||1 Year||1 Year||1 Year|
Our Analysis and Test Results
Motorola and Hubble Connect come together for this monitor combining a Motorola product with a Hubble app and plan. Motorola creates a lot of different electronic products that include smartphones, home phones, monitors, and more. The brand is widely recognized giving them an advantage over other lesser-known manufacturers.
- Buy from somewhere with an easy return policy, in case your internet can't meet the demands of the monitor.
- Be sure to test your new monitor immediately when you receive it, so you don't is a return window should your bandwidth not be up to snuff. Video monitors require more bandwidth than typical movie streaming.
- We suggest using an alternate parent device outside your smartphone for monitoring to avoid potential loss of monitoring when answering or staying on a call.
- Change the password first thing. Immediately! If you don't, you leave yourself open to potential hackers.
This monitor has two different types of range. One is WiFi between the camera and your personal device that should work wherever you have WiFi internet connectivity. The other is the range between the included parent device and the camera, which in our tests was 65 ft through 4 walls in an ordinary home. While you might experience a slightly different range depending on your home's construction and interference, it is a good apples-to-apples comparison to the competition products that give you a general idea if a product can work in your sized home.
Audio / Visual
Sound clarity for the Halo is one of the worst in the group with a score far below the average and generally disappointing. The maximum volume is 82 dB but the maximum volume for clarity is only 69dB. There is no sound activation feature as it makes noise continuously and we think this is a drawback as deep sleep is often easier to find with a silent monitor that only lets crying noise come through. There is no adjustability for sensitivity or noise filtering. The sound is generally clear at lower volumes but gets sticky and harder to discern as the volume gets louder.
The video quality for day images has washed out color but the clarity is pretty good even using the digital zoom which as expected shows some lack of clarity. The images are somewhat better using a tablet or smartphone over the included parent device.
Night video has some dark edges but the image of the baby is still pretty clear. You can see once again that the images from the included parent device (above left) aren't as good as those on a tablet (above right). And the clarity using zoom at night is worse than daytime with some disturbing images coming through.
Ease of Use
This monitor isn't as easy as a true plug and play option, though you could choose to use it as a dedicated monitor ignoring the WiFi capability, but why would you given the price?
Setup of the Halo is a little more involved both for the camera and for the app on your personal device. While you can use the included parent device, we assume if you purchase this monitor that you want to view baby away from home and take advantage of the other features available through the app. You'll need to download, register, and connect your monitor to the app which isn't hard but definitely time-consuming compared to plug and play monitors. Also, you need to connect the monitor to your WiFi system to get connectivity between the camera, its sensors, and the app.
The over-the-crib "halo" mount provides a nice vantage point, but it also requires more setup. The included crib mount is easy to use and feels stable and secure. It has a tube for cord routing that you MUST use to ensure safety and avoid injury or death from little ones coming in to contact with wires and cords.
This monitor also has potential subscription plans to sign up for through Hubble Connections. Plans start at $3 up to $15 depending on the features you are interested in. You need at least the $10 a month plan to get sleep diary capabilities and automatic recording of video history (5 days). The free plan includes, watch and record live videos; motion snapshots; motion, sound, and temperature notifications; download and share snapshots and video; baby growth and development tracker; and sleep tips and videos.
For daily use with the included parent device, this unit is only average for ease of use. The parent device is the same one Motorola has been parading around for at least 5 years so to say it feels dated is an understatement. It is bulkier and heavier than it needs to be with a poor user interface of minimal buttons and menu toggling to find the features you need. It feels like they missed a great opportunity here to make some real improvements on a poor design and we are sad they just repurposed their old parent device with minimal if any improvements.
The app is more intuitive and easier to manage, making us wonder if anyone will bother with the included device which might even be too overwhelming for a grandma to mess with.
The battery life of the included parent device is 9 hours in our tests. We couldn't find a battery life claim from the manufacturer, but depending on your chosen personal device, battery life could be longer if you connect the camera to WiFi and use the app.
This unique monitor has some standard and not so standard features including an above crib mounting system that gives you a good view of the entire crib and baby's face. The app can track your baby's sleep activity and you can even get notifications for movement and temperature. This monitor has loads of bells and whistles, but we aren't convinced parents will use them past the first month or so before it largely turns into an ordinary sound and video monitor of crying baby alerts parents to look at the video and respond.
- Unique overhead view
- 4.3-inch color screen on the parent device
- Nightlight with 7 color options
- Use connected personal devices for viewing
- Sleep quality monitoring
- Sound, motion and temperature notifications
- Remote HD viewing
- 2-way talk to baby
- Detachable camera
- Light show projector, with remote on/off
- Downloadable lullabies and stories
- Out of range and low battery alerts
- LED Sound level indicator
Electromagnetic Field (EMF) Levels
For each monitor, we test the EMF emission levels in our baby gear lab. We compare the EMF levels of each monitor to the competition to get an idea of how one compares to another. Our results are unlikely repeatable in every scenario, but what it shows in the levels compared to the competition to you can see which options offer the least or the most amount of EMF. The Halo EMF was an average of 2.5 at 6 ft from the baby, which is more distance that you'll get using the Halo mounting system. This EMF is far higher than most of the competition and is one of the highest in the group. If EMF is a concern to you, there are better performing competitors in our lineup with far less EMF in our tests.
Finding information about the security and privacy information for this WiFi monitor is more challenging than some of the competition. In reference to the security of the monitor the company simply states
- Check for firmware updates when you first log in
- Change the default password immediately on first use
- Select a complex password that is at least 8-10 characters with both lower and upper case letters, numerals, and special characters if allowed
- Change your password frequently
- Avoid using the same password as another site
- Limit the viewable area of the camera
- Keep the camera unplugged when not in use as some cameras can be turned on remotely.
— Wendy Schmitz