For us, the BabyBjorn Miracle was indeed an improvement on the Original, but still didn't win us over compared to more versatile carriers like Beco Baby Gemini and even the ERGObaby Original. The waist belt and lumbar support did take some of the strain off of our shoulders compared to the BabyBjorn Original, but it still wasn't enough relative to competing carriers. Like the BabyBjorn Original, we love this carrier for newborns, but as baby gets over 4 months we like it less and less relative to competing products which offer more comfortable support, and a wider range of carry positions.
BabyBjorn Miracle Review
Pros: Sturdy, well made, easy to use, close/secure hold, improved back support of BabyBjorn Original
Cons: Limited carry positions, uncomfortable as baby gets older, not toddler friendly
Our Analysis and Test Results
Although it looks a little cumbersome at first, figuring out the BabyBjorn Miracle was fairly uninvolved. The instructions made sense and we like the color-coordinated buckles to help us remember which goes where. Once we had baby in place, they felt secure (minus the leg dangle). We did have some trouble adjusting the baby's seat since the fabric is really thick. It was hard to pull it back or forth as needed. Unfortunately, even with the stiff lumbar support piece, the long term wearability just wasn't what we had hoped.
Like all BabyBjorns we tested, we love that baby can face forward in this carrier. Baby's head and neck are well supported when facing inward and we like that as well. For young babies, newborn to 4 months, the Miracle is great. We love the Original BabyBjorn in this newborn age range, and the Miracle is even better (although bulkier than the original, and considerably more expensive).
Although it wasn't optimal when compared to competitor's approaches, we were grateful for the added lumbar support that relieved our backs and shoulders more than the BabyBjorn Original or BabyBjorn Air.
This carrier is quite a bit bulkier than the other BabyBjorns we tested so it's not as easy to throw in a diaper bag.
Older baby's legs dangle down in this carrier from a seat that is just 4 inches wide. We like the wider seated position of the Beco, ERGO, or Boba better, and we believe those carriers offer better ergonomics for babies aged 4 months and older (the age range when front-carry facing-out is an option). There are also buckles that meet right under baby's seat and they could bother baby after a while.
The back buckle and the front panel buckle meet in the same place so it was hard to maneuver them at times.
The BabyBjorn Miracle improves on the Original but we still find ourselves drawn to competing carriers that offer a wider variety of carry positions, a wider seat, and more support for bigger babies. If your goal is a great carrier for the first 6 months, the Miracle is a choice you won't regret. On the other hand, the BabyBjorn Original is also a great choice for up to 6 months, less bulky, and a lot less expensive. But, if you are looking for a carrier that can work well for newborn to 2-3 years of age, then we'd suggest you look closely at Beco Baby Gemini before you make your final decision.
— Lindsay Ellis