The Kelty Journey PerfectFit is the base model Kelty kids carrier. This economical pack has most of the features you need for a great day of adventures with a design built with comfort in mind. The PerfectFit has nicely padded shoulder straps and a thick waistband with additional structure. It offers load lifters and easy to operate adjustability including a torso adjustment strap you can use on-the-go. This Kelty has a cozy cockpit with a broad padded seat, 5 point harness with covered clips, and stirrups to prevent dangling legs. What the PerfectFit doesn't have is multiple storage options, an included canopy, or anyplace to stow hydration necessities. The lack of features makes it less desirable to dedicated hikers who may lean toward the Kelty Journey PerfectFit Elite which offers more. However, for casual hikers or those who frequent indoor adventures, this wallet-friendly PerfectFit may be just what the doctor ordered for hitting the open trail while saving money.
Kelty Journey PerfectFit Review
Pros: Comfortable for parents and kids, easy to use
Cons: Limited storage and no organizer, no canopy or hydration option
Compare to Similar Products
Kelty Journey PerfectFit
$199.95 at Amazon
$299.95 at Amazon
$299.95 at Amazon
$290.00 at Amazon
$290.00 at Amazon - 3% off
|Pros||Comfortable for parents and kids, easy to use||Comfortable for wearer and passenger, useful storage, easy to use||Comfy to wear and ride in, lots of storage, canopy and hydration pocket||Best child comfort, custom fit possibilities, loads of storage||Comfortable, ample storage, hydration ready|
|Cons||Limited storage and no organizer, no canopy or hydration option||Less supportive seat||Higher price, hard to adjust seat, may be too long for shorter torsos||Doesn't fit all users||Heavy, harder to adjust on the fly|
|Bottom Line||Economical pack that is comfortable for everyone but lacks a canopy and storage||Super comfortable pack that is easy to use with useful storage||Comfortable pack with lots of storage, a canopy, and easy to use features||Super comfortable carrier for parents and children with lots of useful storage||Really comfortable pack with lots of storage|
|Rating Categories||Kelty Journey...||Thule Sapling||Journey PerfectFIT...||Osprey Poco AG Plus||Deuter Kid Comfort 3|
|Parent Comfort (30%)|
|Child Comfort (25%)|
|Ease Of Use (25%)|
|Specs||Kelty Journey...||Thule Sapling||Journey PerfectFIT...||Osprey Poco AG Plus||Deuter Kid Comfort 3|
|Usage Ranges||Age: Not Specified Weight: 16 lbs - 40 lbs Height: Not Specified||Age: Not Specified Weight: 16 lbs - 40 lbs Height: Not Specified||Age: Not Specified Weight: 16 lbs - 40 lbs Height: Not Specified||Age: Not Specified Weight: 16 lbs - 40 lbs Height: Not Specified||Age: Not Specified Weight: 16 lbs - 40 lbs Height: Not Specified|
|Max Pack Load||48.5 lbs||48 lbs||48.5 lbs||48.5 lbs||48.5 lbs|
|Weight||5.5 lbs||7.6 lbs||7.4 lbs||7.9 lbs||7.9 lbs|
|BGL Folded/Flat Dimensions||16" W x 9" H x 31" L||14" W x 14" H x 31" L||16" W x 10" H x 31" L||15" W x 11" H x 30" L||17" W x 10" H x 35" L|
|Fabric||Body: Poly 420D Small Back Stafford Interior: 75D Poly x 140D Nylon Blend||210d Cordura Nylon, 420d Nylon||Body: Poly 420D Small Back Stafford Interior: 75D Poly x 140D Nylon Blend||Main: 210D Nylon Shadow Box Accent: 400HD Nylon Packcloth Bottom: 400HD Nylon Packcloth||Deuter-Super-Polytex (600d PU Coated Polyester)|
|Flame Retardant Chemicals|
|Stirrups||Yes, adjustable||Yes, adjustable straps||Yes, adjustable||Yes, adjustable||Yes, adjustable|
|Hydration Bladder Compatible||No||Yes||Yes||Yes||Yes|
|Included Accessories||Journey Sunshade||Mirror||Stuffed Bear|
|Optional Accessories||Journey Sunshade||Rain Cover||Rain Cover, Carrying Case||Extra Drool Pad, Sun Roof and Rain Cover, KC Deluxe Rain Cover|
|Care Instructions||Spot Clean||Hand Wash||Spot Clean||Hand Wash||Hand Wash|
Our Analysis and Test Results
In 1952, Dick Kelty began making backpacks in his garage for friends. He made welded frames while his wife sewed. Kelty backpacks were utilized by the First American ascent on Mount Everest West Ridge in 1963. By the late 70s, Kelty was making Gore-Tex clothing and six new daypacks. In the early 90s, Kelty began creating child carriers. By 1999, Kelty expanded the kid carrier line to 6 designs.
The comparison chart includes the overall scores for the Kelty Journey PerfectFit (blue) and the competition.
The sections below include details on the PerfectFit's performance during testing.
The PerfectFit is significantly more comfortable to wear than the previous Kelty base pack earning a 9 of 10 for parent comfort.
This pack is a comfy fit with nicely padded straps and a thick waistband (below left) with enough adjustment to sit on your hips. Both straps have a stiff structure to help support baby's weight but it isn't as substantial as the Kelty PerfectFit Elite.
The shoulder straps aren't as adjustable as some of the competition, but they do have the load lifter adjustment (above right) that allows some of the weight of the pack to rest more on your hips than shoulders.
The back of the PerfectFit is padded and covered in breathable material, but the design isn't as breathable as the competition that offers channels for airflow. The lack of flow could lead to a sweaty back.
The torso adjustment is easy to manage and has a range of 4.5 inches, which should be enough for those of average height. Despite the range and the ability to adjust on-the-go, shorter users might end up with the bottom of the carrier resting on the top part of the rear end, while taller users can feel like the torso isn't long enough for all-day comfort.
The PerfectFit is equally comfortable for little passengers with a score of 9 of 10 for child comfort.
Child comfort is critical to keeping little ones content and preventing discomfort related crying and shifting. All of the cockpit and harness adjustments on the PerfectFit operate smoothly, even with baby in the seat.
The cockpit has padded shoulders in the 5-point harness, and the adjustment doesn't impede comfort and it has covered hard clips. The cockpit is roomy enough for movement but not so roomy that the passenger is floppy or feels like they will fall out. The seat is well padded and substantial with a structure that doesn't fold under the baby's weight. It has padding where the legs come out making it more comfortable for hanging legs. The seat is easier to raise up than lower, so it may be easiest to make large adjustments before you put your baby in the pack.
The face pad is cushioned and covered in soft fabric. It is somewhat angled for a more ergonomic napping position when little ones fall asleep and fall forward. The pad is removable for easy cleaning which it will regularly need after napping or eating. You can feel the frame under the pad, but it isn't as significant as some of the competition.
The PerfectFit has stirrups unlike its predecessor, and while not all children use them, it is nice to have the option to prevent dangling legs.
This pack does not come with a canopy, so we urge parents to consider purchasing the canopy listed in accessories below or ensure that little ones are wearing sunhats to prevent sun exposure.
Ease of Use
The PerfectFit is also easier to use than the pack it replaces earning a 7 of 10 for ease of use.
Adjustment of the shoulder straps move smoothly, and the buckles work well with on-the-go adjustability. The torso strap is adjustable when the pack is on, and the waistband is also smooth with a clasp you can operate with one hand in a forward pull motion that requires less effort than back pul designs.
Both the chest clip (above left) and waistbelt (above right) can be adjusted on the go. They have smooth moving belts, and the buckles work well on both.
To adjust the child harness, you use the single internal buckle adjustment (above left) to tighten and loosen. This process is easy to do even with a baby in the cockpit. Moving the seat up and down is done with the adjustment slide on the back of the pack in a pocket behind the seat back (above right). It is easier to raise the seat than to lower it.
This pack has double carry handles on the front and back of the carrier. It is lightweight and the handles work well. The leg brace pops out from the back and creates a stable base.
The PerfectFit earned a 7 of 10 for storage with additional pockets over the previous base model but not as many as the Kelty Journey PerfectFit Elite.
Mulitple and versatile storage options can be the difference between a short jaunt and a more extended hike. If you don't have enough space for your supplies, you'll be taking a shorter trip or carrying an extra pack. This pack does not have water bottle storage or a place for a hydration bladder.
The main storage option on this pack is located on the back with only one waistband pocket within reach of the wearer. The waistband pocket is small with an elastic top and no zipper. It is large enough to fit the average size smartphone, but without a zipper, it could potentially fall out while hiking.
The PerfectFit has one large compartment that is similar in size to the combination of the two compartments found on the PerfectFit Elite. It is large enough to hold most of the supplies you'll need for hiking. However, with a lack of internal dividers or pocket, it can be an organizational nightmare that requires significant searching to find what you are looking for. You'll need help accessing the contents, or you'll have to remove it to reach your supplies.
- Journey Sunshade — This canopy increases the usability of the pack by providing protection for little ones from the sun and inclement weather. This canopy is designed to work with the Journey and can be stored in the canopy pocket.
- Kelty Journey PerfectFit Elite — The Elite is included in this review and won an Editor's Choice award. It is the high-end Kelty pack and comes with all the bells and whistles as well as additional padding and structure that makes wearing it more comfortable. If you want the most pockets and hydration ability, then you'll want to consider the Elite.
- Kelty Journey PerfectFIT Signature — This particular backpack is the middle of the road between the Journey PerfectFIT and the PerfectFIT Elite. It does not have a hydration pocket like the Elite, but it has more features in common with the Elite than the Basic model like a canopy and multiple exterior pockets, some with zippers. If you like the basic option but want a canopy and a slight upgrade without the price bump of the Elite then the Signature is the one for you.
— Juliet Spurrier, MD and Wendy Schmitz