Philips AVENT Straw Cup earned a low 58 out of 100 in our tests. Its top scores were for leakage, which was great since a sippy cup shouldn't leak, but it really came in below average for all the other metrics we tested. For a straw cup it was remarkably hard to drink from. It wasn't alone in the difficult to drink from, with at least 4 other cups scoring lower, but that didn't make better. It also scored low for eco-health, and ease of cleaning. Overall, this cup was nothing special, and other than having the ability to use different lid types with it, and the twist straw lid, there wasn't really anything about it to recommend.
Philips AVENT Straw Cup Review
Pros: Lightweight, twist lid straw storage, leakage
Cons: Low eco-health, difficult to use, harder to clean
Our Analysis and Test Results
Philips AVENT Straw Cup is a BPA-free, plastic, straw sippy cup made by Philips. The cup has a twist top feature that keeps the straw concealed, and protected from debris when not in use. The cup has a silicone straw with an integrated valve to ensure it is leak-proof. It comes in pink and blue, with a active bunny design. The cup lid is interchangeable with the entire AVENT lineup, it has few parts, and is dishwasher safe. The cup has a slightly higher than average price, but still within the reasonable economic sippy range. This sippy is widely available online, and in most stores.
This sippy cup did well in our leakage testing. It scored a 9 of 10, losing just a point for some dripping when held upside down. In fairness though we suspect that was just left over liquid trapped in the straw, not significant leaking from the main body contents, so it certainly wasn't a deal breaker for us.
This cup was very lightweight, and scored well in this metric. Its easy to hold, squat style, and lightweight construction made it easier for toddlers and babies to hold than many of the other cups we reviewed.
We did not like the ease of use of this cup. At first glance it appears to be a pretty straight forward run of the mill sippy, but actually using it was another story. This sippy was difficult to drink from, and scored poorly in this metric. Several other cups scored lower, like the Eco Vessel Stainless Steel Insulated which earned a 1, and the Munchkin Click Lock which earned a 3 of 10, so it wasn't alone in its woes for this metric. However we expected a straw cup to be easier to drink from and require less sucking than most sippy cups not more. This meant it was also not a cup the American Dental Association would recommend. Given their preference for straws they might like this cup, but the hard to drink from valve meant increased sucking, something the ADA is not fond of for oral hygiene.
This cup also scored low for eco-health because it is made primarily of plastic. While it did earn some points for a silicone valve and straw, the body of the cup is made of BPA-free plastic. Given the potential that some plastics may possibly leach chemicals into their contents, especially when exposed to heat, we weren't too keen on any of the plastic cups in our tests.
Philips makes a quality constructed cup with nice interchangeable lid options, and twisting straw storage feature we rather liked. However, at the end of testing, it seemed this cup just failed to measure up to the competition in any metric really. While it was nicely leak free for the most part, many of the cups we tested could boast the same score or higher. So given its lack of above average score in the other categories, it failed to do well, ranking it just 18 out of 21 cups in our tests. Therefore, we had no choice but to not recommend this cup.
— Juliet Spurrier, MD & Wendy Schmitz