Dr. Brown's Carryall Review
Pros: Budget-friendly, simple design, liquid repellent
Cons: Side zipper is main compartment, needs more dividers
Manufacturer: Dr. Browns
Compare to Similar Products
Dr. Brown's Carryall
$49.99 at Amazon
$69.95 at Amazon
|$50 List||$54 List|
$37.99 at Amazon
$20.00 at Amazon
|Pros||Budget-friendly, simple design, liquid repellent||High quality, machine washable, fun designs||High-quality materials, great organization, useful included accessories||Perfect size, included changing pad, stylish design||Budget minded, backpack carry, lots of pockets|
|Cons||Side zipper is main compartment, needs more dividers||Expensive, needs extra insulated area||Does not fit all pumps, not laptop friendly, heavy||Lower quality, fewer pockets, poor structure||Bad zipper, inconsistent quality, doesn't fit larger pumps|
|Bottom Line||Wallet-friendly option with enough features to get the job done on a budget, but not stylish or well organized||A high-quality favorite that offers multiple features with a stylish look, but is heavy and expensive||A bag that provides next-level organization with dual compartments and sturdy materials, but will not fit larger pumps||Large capacity and multi-functional tote that doubles as a diaper bag, but is not good quality||Budget-friendly backpack for pump supplies and personal items but quality control is lacking|
|Rating Categories||Dr. Brown's Carryall||Ju-Ju-Be Be Supplied||Nanobébé Duet||Mommore Breast Pump...||Bananafish Madison|
|Ease of Use (35%)|
|Specs||Dr. Brown's Carryall||Ju-Ju-Be Be Supplied||Nanobébé Duet||Mommore Breast Pump...||Bananafish Madison|
|Dimensions||12.5"W x 7"D x 15.7"H||13"W x 6"D x 12"H||17.3"W x 6"D x 13.8"H||16"W x 8"D x 12"H||15.5"W x 7"D x 12.5"H|
|Weight||1.4 lbs||1.9 lbs||2.4 lbs||1.6 lbs||1.3 lbs|
|Laptop Friendly||Yes - 15"||Yes - 13"||No||Yes||Yes - 13"|
Our Analysis and Test Results
Dr. Brown's has been designing baby gear for over 20 years with items varying from baby bottles to nursing pillows and more. The company works with professionals in the industry, including doctors, to create new products and they typically conduct vast research to ensure product reliability and quality.
Ease of Use
The Carryall is an easy to use bag with few intricacies or features to give you problems. The pump can be used in the bag and the side pockets give easy access for connecting tubes and containers. It would be nice if the bag had more dividers inside for better organization. There is a chance you'll lose smaller items into the void as they can get lodged under the pump or other larger items. It's probably best to put personal items like smartphone and keys in the few pockets to avoid frustration.
For a less expensive bag, this option appears to be better quality than the price would indicate. The bag is well-designed and the materials come together nicely with proper attention to details like stitching and zipper placement. The materials feel durable and we didn't experience any problems with closures or handles.
The Carryall has an average weight of 1.4 lbs and is similar in size to much of the competition. However, it only holds a 13-15-inch laptop without a case or sleeve. Laptops and tablets also slid into the side pocket and aren't as well protected as some of the competition. The bag is fairly large and will get heavy if filled.
The Carryall has external pocket storage and a few inside pockets to keep your supplies organized. The side pockets open to the main space and we'd prefer it be separated from the main bag to keep the pump secluded. However, the space is large enough for bigger pumps and other accessories and you can operate the pump inside the bag. The outside pocket holds tablets or a small laptop and the internal pockets can hold a baby bottle or personal items.
This bag has a shoulder strap and carry handles, which would be nicer if they had padding or skin-friendlier fabric.
This bag has a straightforward style that is simple and somewhat minimalistic. It is a single color with no patterns or bling. This bag has a casual style that could also look at home with business attire thanks to an understated design that doesn't demand center stage. The basic design also indicates that it will work well as a diaper bag or personal bag when your pumping days are over.
— Juliet Spurrier, MD and Wendy Schmitz
Honest, objective reviews. Led by a Pediatrician.
BabyGearLab was founded by a Pediatrician Mom with a mission to provide a reliable, independent, source of information to new parents. Our experts have tested thousands of baby and kids products to share key performance, health, and safety findings. We spend tens of thousands of dollars crash testing car seats to inform our ratings. And, we combine our review work with gobs of expert parenting advice. To assure complete independence, we buy all the products we test ourselves. No sponsored content. No ads. Just real, honest, side-by-side testing by people who care.Learn More