The Arm & Hammer Diaper Pail by Munchkin scored 5th out of the 6 diaper pails we tested. While there are some interesting features with this diaper pail, including earning the high score for ease of bag changes, overall, it scored a 5 out of 10 in odor control, our most important metric in this review. We were surprised that it didn't deliver for odor control because it keeps a seal when the lid is opened or closed and it also sprinkles baking soda every time you add a new dipaer. Overall, we feel you'd be better off with the Diaper Genie Essentials which does better in odor control, baking soda or no baking soda.
Munchkin Arm and Hammer ReviewPrice: $64.75 at Amazon
Pros: Easy to empty bag, child-proofed, baking soda dispenser
Cons: Poor odor control, hand gets caught when disposing of diaper
Bottom line: Better off putting your money into the Diaper Genie Essentials
Estimated Diaper Capacity: Newborn: 30
Type of Refill: Arm and Hammer Refill Bag
RELATED REVIEW: The Best Diaper Pail Review
Our Analysis and Test Results
The Arm and Hammer Diaper Pail by Munchkin uses the power of baking soda to help absorb and neutralize odors associated with dirty diapers. This pail has a dual defense system that sprinkles on the soda with each new diaper addition, and the self-sealing lid locks the bag closed so you don't get the dreaded poof of foul air when you insert the next soiled nappy. Each disposable refill bag holds up to 30 diapers and the bags snap and seal shut so very little odor escapes when changing the bag for a new refill. The side door allows for quick bag changes, and there is no cut and tie procedure that might involve run off from dirty diapers getting on your hands. The list price for this pail is $30, though a newer version is available on Amazon for around $49.
Diaper Champ Deluxe. Unfortunately, the lid seal starts to have trouble as the bag fills and the tension on the lid grows resulting in odor escaping. We really had high hopes for this model both because of the baking powder and the self-sealing, but it just didn't do well in our sniff test and the wafting odor when dirty diapers are put inside is more than any parent should have to suffer. While this pail didn't have the lowest score for odor control in our tests, that was an honor earned by the Ubbi, it still wasn't impressive enough to earn a place in our hearts.
Ease of Disposal
Ease of Bag Changes
There is a child-proof, locking door for access to the bag, and the door stays open widely with a click which makes removing the bag much easier. We liked the design of the refills both for putting in and taking out. The snap and seal design limits the amount of noxious fumes that can escape when changing the bag and that is a big plus in our book. We also like that the snap prevents stray diapers from falling out. In addition, its kind of nice not to have to deal with the cutting and the tying of some of the other bags, like the Diaper Genies and the Diaper Dekor.
With a 5th place rank and a relatively low score for odor control there probably isn't a best application for this pail. Some parents might very well be attracted to the Munchkin name or even the tried and true favorite of Arm and hammer Baking Soda for odor control, but this pail disappoints and failed to match the sniff test results of other models. So despite having one of the easiest proprietary bags to change and remove from a pail with an easy to use snap and seal top, it still wasn't enough to find this pail a home or a best application use.
Value/Estimated Lifetime Cost
Diaper Genie Essentials which scored 75 of 100. Even the Best Value choice, Diaper Champ had 7 points more than the Munchkin and it scored higher for odor control. In the end, we were certainly intrigued by this pail, but it didn't bring its game face to our tests and in our opinion didn't offer the odor control parents are likely to expect. This makes the Munchkin a pail we don't recommend.
Other Versions and Accessories
Munchkin does not make any other kind of diaper disposal system. They do sell refill inserts for their bags and baking soda dispensers (for about $4 per cup).
Bag Change Challenge
BabyGearLab Member Reviews
Most recent review: May 11, 2015
Have you used this product?
Don't hold back. Share your viewpoint by posting a review with your thoughts...