< Go to Disposable Diapers

Hands-on Gear Review

Pampers Swaddlers Review

Price:   $0.33 List | $0.23 each (in 124-pack) at Amazon
Pros:  Quality, soft, good absorbency
Cons:  Poor eco/health, price
Bottom line:  Better than Huggies, but there are more compelling options
Editors' Rating:     
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Manufacturer:   Procter & Gamble

The Skinny

Pampers is one of the most famous brand-name diapers; it is widely available, has an average price, and Swaddlers is one of their most popular versions. In our tests it did well in absorption, scoring an 8 out of 10, and overall it ranked 8 out of 24 diapers tested. It's price was higher than Huggies Snug & Dry, but less than Huggies Little Snugglers, and Huggies green diaper Pure & Natural. However, its overall performance was better than any Huggies variety. Pampers failed to meet any eco/health metrics earning a score of 1 out of 10 for both. While it did perform better than average, it just wasn't a diaper we can recommend. With Earth's Best Tender Care scoring higher in our tests, we felt it was the better choice offering more eco/health attributes.


RELATED REVIEW: The Battle for the Best Disposable Diapers

select up to 5 products
Score Product Price Our Take
82
$0
Editors' Choice Award
Best diaper, amazing absorption, higher price, but worth it
67
$0
Great performing green diaper at an ok price
65
$1
Adequate performance, but most expensive diaper we tested
64
$0
Eco-healthy, w/ great absorbency, if your budget allows
63
$0
Competing green diapers have lower price w/ similar performance
62
$0
Best Value Award
Great green diaper for a nice price
58
$0
Not that different from Swaddlers regular
53
$0
Better than Huggies, but there are more compelling options
49
$0
Best Value Award
Low performance, but it is the best value diaper
48
$1
Nice try, but there are better green diapers for less $
46
$0
Most green diapers rated higher
46
$0
Adequate green diaper that is easy on the wallet
44
$0
Several diapers scored higher & cost less
43
$0
Good price, but there are better diapers w/ similar price
43
$0
Ok, nice health considerations, but nothing to love
42
$0
Other green diapers scored higher for a similar price
41
$0
Ok for the price, but not the best
41
$0
Better diapers available w/ a cheaper price
35
$0
Most green diapers scored better; this not the "clear" choice
34
$0
The price is good, but the diaper isn't
33
$0
Good price, but poor performance
33
$0
Lackluster and doesn't live up to its name
30
$0
Cheap, but largely ineffective
23
$0
Better, cheaper, eco-health options available

Our Analysis and Hands-on Test Results

Review by:
Juliet Spurrier, MD
Mom-in-Chief
BabyGearLab

Last Updated:
Thursday
June 5, 2014

Share:
Pampers Swaddlers is a brand name diaper that is very popular with new parents. It offers a very soft cover, special wick away liner for urine and thicker things, and a great absorption ability. It boasts breathable sides, wetness indicator, and a fresh scent. It has a slightly higher than average price and it ranked 8 out of the 24 diapers we tested. Many parents are given these diapers while still in the hospital when baby is born.

Performance Comparison



Absorption and Leaks


Swaddlers standout category in our tests was absorption.
Swaddlers was thinner than some other diapers we tested  but it still had about the same increase in size once saturated. Note the wetness indicator stripe
Swaddlers was thinner than some other diapers we tested, but it still had about the same increase in size once saturated. Note the wetness indicator stripe
With a score of 8 of 10, it did better than all but 2 other diapers in this metric and tied with still 2 others. Nature Babycare earned a perfect 10 for absorption in our tests, with BAMBO Nature, our Editors' Choice, earning a 9. Both diapers however, were more expensive. In its price range, Swaddlers only competition was Swaddlers Sensitive which also earned an 8. Neither diaper offered anything for eco/health however, which made Earth's Best Tender Care and BAMBO Nature the two top contenders we tested if being green is as important as absorption. Huggies Snug & Dry came close to Swaddlers with a score of 7 and it is significantly cheaper.

The absorption test for Huggies Snug & Dry (left), Pamper Swaddlers (middle), and Nature Babycare (right) are shown below. The larger green area indicates more surface moisture; less green indicates better absorption.
 

The diaper dropped below average in our tests for leaks, with a score of 4 of 10. It had lots of company in this price range, with most of the diapers we tested scoring in the 4-6 range. Earth's Best Tender Care scored a 9, and was higher overall than Swaddlers, and was about the same price. The only diapers in its price range to score lower, were green diapers Seventh Generation Free & Clear and Huggies green diaper Pure & Natural. Both diapers were more expensive and ranked lower.

Comfort and Durability


 

Swaddlers did not earn a very high score for comfort in our tests. It received a 4 of 10, which placed it below average out of the diapers we tested. It earned 3 out of 5 for the softness of the materials used, and the back and side elastic softness compared to other diapers, but it lost points for the feel and positioning of the closure tabs.
Inner thigh chafe with Pampers Swaddler
Inner thigh chafe with Pampers Swaddler

All Pampers products have the same tab set-up, which places a relatively stiff material on the inside of the diaper, allowing baby's skin to rub on the connection point. We feel that the more comfortable diapers connect the tab on the outside of the diaper and utilize softer materials next to baby's skin.

Many competitors came in with higher comfort scores in our tests; including Huggies Little Snugglers and Pure & Natural, earning 6 and 7 respectfully. Cuties, one of our Best Value winners, earned a 6 out 10 in this metric, and it scored just slightly lower overall. But, with a price that is cheaper on average than Swaddlers, it might just be the better choice.

In the area of durability, Swaddlers fared better in our tests than it did in comfort with a score of 7. The diaper had a genuine quality feel and fit, with very few complaints of construction problems, or missing or easily broken tabs (common complaints for some diapers we tested). Out of the top 8 diapers in our tests, it did have the second highest score for this metric with only BAMBO Nature scoring higher with an 8. In its price range, Huggies Snugglers came in at 7 as well, with green diapers Earth's Best Tender Care (a Best Value Winner), and Seventh Generation Free & Clear both earning a 6.

Eco and Health


Proctor and Gamble's diaper brands Pampers and Luvs do not advertise eco-friendly claims like being biodegradable or free of chlorine, latex, perfume, or dyes. If you dig deep into the Pampers website FAQ, you can find a few cryptically worded, and well-crafted answers, which actually say nothing but sound super fancy. This sleight of hand wording left us scratching our heads about what Pampers means. For example, one FAQ on the Pampers site asks: "Do your diapers contain dioxin?"

Pampers Village's updated post from July 23, 2009 states:
Our suppliers use elemental chlorine free processes that do not result in the formation of dioxin. The methods we use to analyze for dioxin are the most advanced government-approved testing methods available, and can detect even minute amounts of dioxin, if present.

Purification of the pulp fibers used to make Pampers and Luvs is done to eliminate the impurities which would inhibit our ability to make clean absorbent fibers. By cleaning the fibers in this manner, we can make a better performing product with fewer raw materials, which has clear benefits for the environment. Whitening the fibers is a result of this process, but is not its goal.

Our opinion is that the above answer is unsatisfactory, and possibly misleading. Many competing diaper brands provide clear statements that their diaper is "chlorine-free"; while Pampers answer remains unclear. Pampers vague and non-committal answer only gives information about suppliers, but fails to tell us if the diaper is chlorine-free or not. Okay, their suppliers "use elemental chlorine free processes" and Pampers has "advanced government-approved testing methods," but are they chlorine-free? We don't know, and their answer doesn't tell us. Competing brands avoid vague and confusing answers, so we assume Pampers is intentionally not answering the question, and possibly trying to hide something. Is their carefully worded, vague yet scientific sounding, response a direct answer or intentional misleading fun with words?

In addition, Pampers claims it does not use dyes but uses "colorants" or "pigments" instead. They even claim color transfer from diaper to baby is "normal" and "safe". We feel that saying you are dye free, but using "pigments" or "colorants" is yet again just another way of misleading consumers who don't have the time, knowledge, or skills to pursue the claim further. While there may be a difference between the two, several dictionaries consider the words to be "synonyms", which means they are interchangeable and are essentially the same thing. If Pampers would like to clarify why their pigments are better or safer than dyes, that would be a good answer to the dye question, instead of just saying they a "Dye-free".

Overall, Sawddlers scored a 1 in both eco and health categories. With no claims to the contrary, and only vague, hard to decipher answers, we were unable to determine that Pampers offered anything up for the Earth or your baby. In its price range it was not a top performer; both Earth's Best Tender Care and Nature Babycare scored higher in our tests in both metrics, and both diapers scored higher overall, with Nature Babycare even beating Swaddlers in absorption with a perfect 10.

Best Applications


Parents looking for a popular name brand diaper are likely to be drawn to Pampers. With brand familiarity, and the appearance of hospital endorsement, it is easy to see why new parents would try Pampers almost by default.
General overall cozy fit and cloth-like look and feel
General overall cozy fit and cloth-like look and feel
The price is just slightly above average and similar to other top name brands and some green diapers. With an overall rank of 8 out of 24 it is not a bad diaper and even has some lovely qualities like super softness. If a good traditional diaper is what you are looking for, Cuties scored almost the same in every metric tested, with only absorption being lower in our tests and both comfort and durability rating higher. If its similar score wasn't enough to sway you, it costs less on average. It may not be a familiar brand, but it is almost as good and will probably save you money.

Conclusion


Overall Swaddlers ranked 8 out of the 24 diapers tested. It showed impressive scores for absorption and durability in our tests, but it came in below average for leaks and higher in price. While it has an overall quality fit and feel, the tradeoff is potential leaks, no pluses for baby health, and no consideration to the environment. All of which makes it a diaper not worthy of its popularity.

If brand name popularity is your driving factor we suggest Earth's Best Tender Care, a Best Value winner. It has a name consumers know, is a green diaper, scored higher overall, and has a similar price. If budget is a concern, consider our other Best Value winner, Cuties, which scored a 49 of 100 in our tests compared to Swaddlers 53 and is cheaper on average.

The photos below show the absorbency results for Cuties (left), Pampers Swaddlers (middle), and Earth's Best (right).
 

Swaddlers did score above average, but given its misleading and confusing marketing and diaper component explanation, along with very little consideration to baby's health and (we assume) the use of chlorine, dyes, fragrances and latex, it is not a diaper we recommend. There are diapers that are just as good and offer increased health benefits even on a budget.

Other Versions


 
Pampers has several other diaper types, including Swaddlers Sensitive, Baby Dry, Cruisers and Baby Dry Extra Protection. We only tested the Swaddlers and Swaddlers Sensitive. Swaddlers Sensitive has a touch of aloe, a little less dye, and a poorer absorption. In general, there was little difference to merit the higher price. If you are feeling particularly adventurous, you could try the other varieties, but we feel that for the money there are better diapers available that offer more for baby and the Earth.
Juliet Spurrier, MD & BabyGearLab Team

  • Share this article:

Where to Buy?

Reseller Price  Shipping Cost Visit
Amazon $0.23
(in 124-pack)
Check Site

Thinking about buying some gear we've reviewed? Help BabyGearLab out if you do. Just click on any of the above links and if you make any purchase, a portion of sale helps support this site. It won't cost you anything extra, and it's a simple way to help us fund things like our gear reviews. Thanks!

*Most retailers free shipping offers apply only to lower 48 US states, and for ground/economy shipping. See retailer's website for details.


BabyGearLab Member Reviews


Most recent review: June 14, 2016
Summary of All Ratings

BabyGearLab Editors' Rating:   
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
 (4.0)
Average Customer Rating:   
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
 (5.0)

100% of 3 reviewers recommend it
Rating Distribution
4 Total Ratings
5 star: 75%  (3)
4 star: 25%  (1)
3 star: 0%  (0)
2 star: 0%  (0)
1 star: 0%  (0)
Sort 3 member reviews by: Most Recent | Most Helpful
Write a Review on this Gear

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
   Jun 14, 2016 - 10:26am
Annie23 · Houston, TX
I have been a cloth diapering/ pamper using mom to my 3 kiddos, and they have proven to be the most absorbent, least residue leaving diapers of all that I've tried (Luvs, up&up, earths best, babyganics, honest). They are the only diapers I feel keep my baby's bottom dry and don't leave SAP crystals on their bottoms. I recently emailed pampers with my concerns with dioxin, and this is the response I received. Thought I would share in case it helps anyone.

Thank you for reaching out, Annie.

We appreciate you reaching out with your concerns for your daughter,and I do want to assure you that our diapers are safe. All pulps used in our diapers have been thoroughly safety tested and are derived from environmentally sound manufacturing operations. The pulp and tissue used in our Pampers diapers are produced via a bleaching process that is either elemental chlorine-free (ECF) or total chlorine-free (TCF).

These modern pulp bleaching methods are regarded by both experts and regulatory authorities worldwide as safe and effective processes. We use an ingredient that has been approved by the FDA for the safe treatment of drinking water to process the wood-based pulp in our diapers. While this is referred to as a "bleaching" process, our diapers do not contain bleach or chlorine, and nothing is left behind in the diaper after the process.

I hope this helps ease your mind about our diapers, Annie. Please let us know if you have any other questions or comments.

Gina
Pampers Team

Bottom Line: Yes, I would recommend this product to a friend.
Help other readers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? 
Yes
 
No

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
   Feb 25, 2016 - 02:04am
Kapoor · Mumbai
I am a regular user of Pampers diaper for my son since his birth . I am a doctor by profession and I found that its working fine. It take care of baby skin and absorb the liquid to keep baby skind dry for longer hours http://pamper.buydiapers.co.in

Bottom Line: Yes, I would recommend this product to a friend.
Help other readers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? 
Yes
 
No

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
   Aug 31, 2014 - 12:24pm
Alexis · New York
I feel like Pampers are unfairly relegated to the bottom of the barrel here. While the low marks for eco-friendliness and being made with "healthy" materials are justified, unlike the top ranking brands tested here (All of which I have tried through at least 20 diapers), Pampers are the best at keeping my infants perineum dry and, probably most importantly to me, containing leaks. Only Pampers and Bambo diapers were leak-proof in my experience, and as such they are the 2 brands I predominantly use.

After my infant ended up with a horrible candidal diaper rash that would not abate despite anti-fungal treatment during a test run of another, higher ranked brand, I switched back to Pampers and the rash disappeared overnight. As a practicing pediatrician, I used to discount such tales from parents, but now I've seen it for myself - call me a convert!

The sensitive version is superior to me because they are fragrance free, but both are extremely popular brands with good reason.

Bottom Line: Yes, I would recommend this product to a friend.
Help other readers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? 
Yes
 
No


Have you used the Pampers Swaddlers?
Don't hold back. Share your viewpoint by posting a review with your thoughts...

Write a Review on this Gear
 
Where to Buy?
Seller Price
Amazon $0.23 (in 124-pack)

*You help support BabyGearLab's product testing and reviews by purchasing from our retail partners.
Related Review
Babies depend on their caregivers to provide comfort and security. Parents depend on diapers to keep babies dry and comfortable. You can depend on BabyGearLab for objective scientific reviews of diapers so you can quickly find the best product for your family.
The Battle for the Best Disposable Diapers

by Juliet Spurrier, MD & BabyGearLab Team
Helpful Buying Tips
Your baby will go through 2 500-3 000 diapers in the first year alone. Choosing the right one for you and your baby is a key decision.
 How to Choose the Best Disposable Diaper

by Juliet Spurrier, MD & BabyGearLab Team

Follow Us

Unbiased.